Bugesera invasion: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
RussBot (talk | contribs)
m Robot: Editing intentional link to disambiguation page in hatnote per WP:INTDABLINK (explanation)
 
(29 intermediate revisions by 18 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{shortShort description|1963 attacksInyenzi onrebels attacks and massacres in Rwanda}}
{{Other uses|Bloody Christmas (disambiguation){{!}}Bloody Christmas}}
{{good article}}
 
{{Other uses|Bloody Christmas (disambiguation){{!}}Bloody Christmas}}{{Infobox military conflict
| conflict = Bugesera invasion
| partof =
| image =
| caption =
| date = 21–27 December 1963
| place = Rwanda
| result = Rwandan government victory
* Anti-Tutsi massacres in Rwanda
| combatant1 = Inyenzi<br/>'''Supported by:'''<br/>{{flag|China}}
| combatant2 = {{flag|Rwanda|1962}}<br/>'''Supported by:'''<br/>{{flag|Belgium}}
| commander1 = [[François Rukeba]]<br/>[[Kigeli V Ndahindurwa|Kigeli V]]&nbsp;<small>(disputed)</small>
| commander2 = [[Grégoire Kayibanda]]<br/>[[Juvénal Habyarimana]]&nbsp;<small>(disputed)</small>
| units1 = Armée Royale Rwandaise
| units2 = [[Rwanda Defence Force|Garde Nationale Rwandaise]]
| strength1 = Hundreds of exiles<br/>Hundreds or thousands of supporters
| strength2 = {{circa}} 1,000 soldiers<br/>{{circa}} 50 Belgian military advisers
| casualties1 = Hundreds killed
| casualties2 = 44–9 soldiers killed
| casualties3 = 10,000–20,000 Tutsi civilians killed in subsequent reprisals
| campaignbox =
}}
The '''Bugesera invasion''' ([[French language|French]]: ''Invasion de Bugesera''), also known as the '''Bloody Christmas''' (French: ''Noël Rouge''),{{sfn|Strizek|1996|pp=146, 156}} was a military attack which was conducted against Rwanda by Inyenzi rebels who aimed to overthrow the government in December 1963. The Inyenzi were a collection of ethnically [[Tutsi]] exiles who were affiliated with the Rwandan political party [[Rwandese National Union|Union Nationale Rwandaise]] (UNAR), which had supported Rwanda's deposed Tutsi monarchy. The Inyenzi opposed Rwanda's transformation upon independence from Belgium into a state run by the ethnic [[Hutu]] majority through the [[Parmehutu|Parti du Mouvement de l'Emancipation Hutu]] (PARMEHUTU), an anti-Tutsi political party led by President [[Grégoire Kayibanda]]. In late 1963, Inyenzi leaders decided to launch an invasion of Rwanda from their bases in neighbouring countries to overthrow Kayibanda. While an attempted assault in November was stopped by the government of [[Burundi]], early in the morning on 21 December 1963, several hundred Inyenzi crossed the Burundian border and captured the Rwandan military in camp in Gako, [[Bugesera District|Bugesera]]. Bolstered with seized arms and recruited locals, the Iyenzi—numbering between 1,000–7000 and 7,000—marched on the Rwandan capital, [[Kigali]]. They were stopped {{convert|12 miles (19 kilometres)|mi|km|abbr=off}} south of the city at Kanzenze Bridge along the [[Nyabarongo River]] by multiple units of the [[Rwanda Defence Force|Garde Nationale Rwandaise]] (GNR). The GNR routed the rebels with their superior firepower, and in subsequent days repelled further Inyenzi attacks launched from the [[Republic of the Congo (Léopoldville)|Republic of the Congo]] and [[Uganda]].
 
Shortly after the invasion, the Rwandan regime moved to purge moderate Hutu and leading Tutsi politicians. About 20 opposition leaders from UNAR and the Rassemblement Démocratique du Rwanda were accused of collaborating with the rebels, arrested, and executed in [[Ruhengeri]]. Kayibanda assigned ministers in his government to each of the country's ten prefectures—dubbed "emergency regions"—and granted them emergency powers to defend them, including the responsibility of organising Hutu "self-defence" militias. The militias conducted systematic reprisals against Tutsis, with the most intense violence occurring in the [[Gikongoro Province|prefecture of Gikongoro]]. Killings lasted into January 1964, with estimates of the death toll reaching as high as 20,000 Tutsi killed. Thousands more fled the country. The massacres provoked international outcry and accusations of [[genocide]], which were denied by the Rwandan government. The invasion and subsequent reprisals left UNAR's domestic bases of support destroyed and resulted in Rwanda becoming a ''de facto'' one-party PARMEHUTU state, while the status of the GNR was also improved. Inyenzi attacks persisted for several years but were easily repulsed. There remains disagreement over whether the reprisal killings of Tutsis constituted genocide.
Line 31 ⟶ 32:
=== Rwandan Revolution ===
{{main|Rwandan Revolution}}
[[File:Stamp of Rwanda - 1969 - Colnect 588946 - Worker with Pickaxe and Flag.jpeg|thumb|170px|left|1969 stamp celebrating the [[Rwandan Revolution]]. ]]
[[File:Epinglette Kigeli V 01.JPG|left|thumb|Brass lapel pin ''Vive [[Kigeli V Ndahindurwa|Kigeli V]]'' "Long Live Kigeli V" from the time of the revolution.]]
Following the end of [[World War I]] in 1918, the victorious states partitioned the colonies of the defeated [[German Empire]]. Belgium was awarded the [[League of Nations mandate|mandate]] of [[Ruanda-Urundi]]—two conjoined territories in East Africa—under the auspices of the [[League of Nations]].{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=34}} In Ruanda, the Belgian colonial administration undermined the traditional monarchy, promoted [[Christianity]], and centralised governance under their direct rule.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=34–35}} As part of this, the Belgians institutionalised a racial hierarchy which favoured the [[Tutsi]] ethnic minority at the expense of the [[Hutu]] majority. The Belgians supported racial theories which held the Tutsis to be of superior, non-African origin and entrusted them with privileged access to education and administrative positions, while most Hutus were relegated to economic subservience to help Belgian businesses.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=35–36}}
 
Ruanda's population became heavily Christian, and most of its Christians were [[Roman Catholicism|Catholic]].{{sfn|Melvern|2000|p=20}} A small Hutu counter-elite began to form after [[World War II]], consisting of persons who had been granted access to education and publications through the Catholic Church.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=36}} Catholic officials maintained close links with the Hutu elite.{{sfn|Melvern|2000|p=20}} The latter began to promote an ideology known as [[Hutu Power]], which challenged Tutsi-minority domination of Ruanda as an exploitation of the majority by foreigners. One of the new leaders of the Hutu elite was [[Grégoire Kayibanda]], a former seminarian who had edited Catholic publications.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=36–37}} In October 1959 Kayibanda founded the [[Parmehutu|Parti du Mouvement de l'Emancipation Hutu]] (PARMEHUTU, Party of the Hutu Emancipation Movement), a political party which called for the end of Tutsi domination of social life and rejected anti-European hostility and supported gradual democratisation.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=38}} At around the same time, conservative Tutsi created the [[Rwandese National Union|Union Nationale Rwandaise]] (UNAR, Rwandese National Union), a party which demanded immediate independence under the Tutsi monarchy. Other parties such as the Rassemblement Démocratique du Rwanda (RADER, Democratic Rally of Rwanda), a moderate grouping, were created but failed to gain popular traction. The Belgians began to show favour towards the staunchly Catholic and anticommunist Hutu elite, as the Tutsi elite and UNAR became more aligned with anticolonialism and socialism.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=37–38}} Following a period of ethnic unrest in late 1959 and a Belgian military intervention, the colonial administration replaced a substantial amount of Tutsi chiefs with Hutus. In June 1960 the Belgians hosted municipal elections which were overwhelmingly won by PARMEHUTU.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=38–39}}
In January 1961 thousands of Ruandan municipal officials gathered in [[Muhanga|Gitarama]] and, acting as a constituent assembly, [[coup of Gitarama|voted to dissolve the monarchy]] and replace it with a presidential system. The proposed president, [[Dominique Mbonyumutwa]], then requested that Kayibanda form a new government.{{sfn|Mamdani|2002|p=124}}{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=193}} This arrangement was later altered to give Kayibanda the presidency.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=193}} In the September [[1961 Rwandan parliamentary election]], PARMEHUTU won an overwhelming majority of the seats in the [[Parliament of Rwanda|Legislative Assembly]]. Concurrent to the elections was a referendum on the decision to abolish the monarchy; the population voted in favour of abolition.{{sfn|Harroy|1989|p=475}} In February 1962 the United Nations brokered a compromise, the New York Accord,{{sfn|Mushemeza|2007|p=65}} in attempt to ensure Rwandan politics remained inclusive. The agreement called for Kayibanda and PARMEHUTU to form a coalition government with UNAR,{{sfn|Mamdani|2020|pp=126–128}} guaranteeing the latter two ministerial portfolios in the government.<ref name= emmanuel/> The accord split UNAR into an accommodationist faction committed to working through the coalition, and a restorationist faction intent on using armed force to attack the new government.{{sfn|Mamdani|2020|pp=126–128}} On 17 May 1962 [[Michel Rwagasana]], a leader of UNAR's accommodationist faction, declared before the Legislative Assembly that UNAR was committed to working with the Rwandan government. The restorationists were deeply angered by this statement and it resulted in a total fracture in the party between those who remained in Rwanda and those in exile.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=202–203}}
 
In January 1961 thousands of Ruandan municipal officials gathered in [[Muhanga|Gitarama]] and, acting as a constituent assembly, [[coup of Gitarama|voted to dissolve the monarchy]] and replace it with a presidential system. The proposed president, [[Dominique Mbonyumutwa]], then requested that Kayibanda form a new government.{{sfn|Mamdani|2002|p=124}}{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=193}} This arrangement was later altered to give Kayibanda the presidency.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=193}} In the September [[1961 Rwandan parliamentary election]], PARMEHUTU won an overwhelming majority of the seats in the [[Parliament of Rwanda|Legislative Assembly]]. Concurrent to the elections was a referendum on the decision to abolish the monarchy; the population voted in favour of abolition.{{sfn|Harroy|1989|p=475}} In February 1962 the United Nations brokered a compromise, the New York Accord,{{sfn|Mushemeza|2007|p=65}} in attempt to ensure Rwandan politics remained inclusive. The agreement called for Kayibanda and PARMEHUTU to form a coalition government with UNAR,{{sfn|Mamdani|2020|pp=126–128}} guaranteeing the latter two ministerial portfolios in the government.<ref name= emmanuel/> The accord split UNAR into an accommodationist faction committed to working through the coalition, and a restorationist faction intent on using armed force to attack the new government.{{sfn|Mamdani|2020|pp=126–128}} The restorationist faction organized itself as "UNAR extérieure" in exile.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}} On 17 May 1962 [[Michel Rwagasana]], a leader of UNAR's accommodationist faction, declared before the Legislative Assembly that UNAR was committed to working with the Rwandan government. The restorationists were deeply angered by this statement and it resulted in a total fracture in the party between those who remained in Rwanda and those in exile.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=202–203}}
Ruanda-Urundi became independent as the two states of [[Rwanda]] and [[Burundi]] on 1 July 1962.<ref name = nyt/> Kayibanda became President of Rwanda. Fearful of majority rule and facing violence, thousands of Tutsis fled to neighbouring countries. Burundi, which retained a Tutsi monarchy, was the most welcoming for the refugees.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=39}} The UNAR restorationists formed a government-in-exile, with [[François Rukeba]] as Prime Minister.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=203}}{{efn|After the Bugesera invasion, the Rwandan military claimed to had captured "two red-and‐white guerrilla flags reputed to belong to a revolutionary government".<ref name = nyt/> }} They hoped to place King [[Kigeli V Ndahindurwa]] back on the throne through force.<ref name = nyt>{{cite news |title=Savagery Marks Tribal Warfare in Rwanda; Watasi, Once Feudal Lords, Flee to Neighboring Lands —Bahatu Kill Thousands; Regime Said to Permit Raids as Reprisals for Terrorism by Monarchist Guerrillas |url=https://www.nytimes.com/1964/02/09/archives/savagery-marks-tribal-warfare-in-rwanda-watasi-once-feudal-lords.html |newspaper=[[The New York Times]] |page=1 |date=9 February 1964 }}</ref> However, the exiled UNAR elements were deeply divided, fragmented and disorganised. As they were spread across several countries, communication was arduous and slow, making coordinated actions difficult.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|p=26}} The party organisation was also weak, and rivalries between different factions hampered the resistance against the Rwandan government: While the UNAR exiles were led by Kigeli and reactionary monarchists, a substantial left-leaning group existed at the basis. In exile, the UNAR's [[Marxism|Marxist]] wing gradually grew more influential.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|pp=26–27}} Internal disagreements led to a reforming of the government-in-exile in May 1963 with [[Michel Kayihura]] as Prime Minister and Rukeba retained as Minister of Defence.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=204}} In February 1963 Kayibanda dropped the UNAR ministers from his government.<ref name= emmanuel>{{cite web| url = https://www.sciencespo.fr/mass-violence-war-massacre-resistance/en/document/rwanda-chronology-1867-1994| title = Rwanda - A Chronology (1867-1994)| first = Emmanuel| last = Viret| date = 1 March 2010| website = Mass Violence & Résistance| publisher = [[Sciences Po]]| access-date = 8 June 2021}}</ref>
 
Ruanda-Urundi became independent as the two states of [[Rwanda]] and [[Burundi]] on 1 July 1962.<ref name = nyt/> Kayibanda became President of Rwanda. Fearful of majority rule and facing violence, thousands of Tutsis fled to neighbouring countries. Burundi, which retained a Tutsi monarchy, was the most welcoming for the refugees.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=39}} The UNAR restorationists formed a government-in-exile, with [[François Rukeba]] as Prime Minister.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=203}}{{efn|After the Bugesera invasion, the Rwandan military claimed to had captured "two red-and‐white guerrilla flags reputed to belong to a revolutionary government".<ref name = nyt/> }} They hoped to place King [[Kigeli V Ndahindurwa]] back on the throne through force.<ref name = nyt>{{cite news |title=Savagery Marks Tribal Warfare in Rwanda; Watasi, Once Feudal Lords, Flee to Neighboring Lands —Bahatu Kill Thousands; Regime Said to Permit Raids as Reprisals for Terrorism by Monarchist Guerrillas |url=https://www.nytimes.com/1964/02/09/archives/savagery-marks-tribal-warfare-in-rwanda-watasi-once-feudal-lords.html |newspaper=[[The New York Times]] |page=1 |date=9 February 1964 }}</ref> However, the exiled UNAR elements were deeply divided, fragmented and disorganised. As they were spread across several countries, communication was arduous and slow, making coordinated actions difficult.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|p=26}} The party organisation was also weak, and rivalries between different factions hampered the resistance against the Rwandan government: While the UNAR exiles were led by Kigeli and reactionary monarchists, a substantial left-leaning group existed at the basis. In exile, the UNAR's [[Marxism|Marxist]] wing gradually grew more influential.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|pp=26–27}}{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}} Internal disagreements led to a reforming of the government-in-exile in May 1963 with [[Michel Kayihura]] as Prime Minister and Rukeba retained as Minister of Defence.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=204}} In February 1963 Kayibanda dropped the UNAR ministers from his government.<ref name= emmanuel>{{cite web| url = https://www.sciencespo.fr/mass-violence-war-massacre-resistance/en/document/rwanda-chronology-1867-1994| title = Rwanda - A Chronology (1867-1994)| first = Emmanuel| last = Viret| date = 1 March 2010| website = Mass Violence & Résistance| publisher = [[Sciences Po]]| access-date = 8 June 2021}}</ref>
 
=== Inyenzi and GNR ===
[[File:Epinglette Kigeli V 01.JPG|leftright|thumb|Brass lapel pin ''Vive [[Kigeli V Ndahindurwa|Kigeli V]]'' "Long Live Kigeli V" from the time of the revolution[[Rwandan Revolution]].]]
Early UNAR Tutsi insurgent activity was confined to acts of terrorism against specific individuals and families. As more Tutsi refugees fled Rwanda, UNAR's exile ranks grew, and more systematic attempts were made to raise bands of combatants to launch raids on targeted areas. Violence in Rwanda dramatically increased as Tutsis fled ''en masse'' in early 1960; the first acts of violence were retaliatory attacks by Tutsis against Hutu officials who had mistreated them, but by early 1962 planned raids had become predominant. These were intended to inflict maximum damage to the Hutu-dominated administration and were generally conducted without consideration for government reprisals on local Tutsis.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=217}} By 1963, about 60,000 Tutsi refugees were living in the [[Republic of the Congo (Léopoldville)|Republic of the Congo]], 48,000 in Uganda, 25,000 in Burundi, and 16,000 in [[Tanganyika (1961–1964)|Tanganyika]].<ref name = nyt/> As the insurgents were known to attack at night, they were called Inyenzi, meaning "cockroaches". It is unknown whether the rebels themselves or officials of the Kayibanda regime coined the term. While later used in a derogatory sense against Tutsis generally, most contemporary sources refer to the exile rebels with the term in a non-pejorative fashion.{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=184}} The [[People's Republic of China]] also provided the guerillas with training opportunities and financial support.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=39–40}}{{efn|The People's Republic of China reportedly chose to support the rebels as a response to Kayibanda's denunciations of communism and his recognition of [[Chiang Kai-shek]]'s [[Taiwan|rival Chinese government]].<ref>{{cite news| last = Sulzberger| first = C. L.| title = Foreign Affairs: Prince Charlie and the Cockroaches| newspaper = The New York Times| page = 30| date = 6 April 1964}}</ref>}} The Tutsi rebels reportedly also enlisted some defectors of the [[Armée Nationale Congolaise]] (National Congolese Army),<ref name = nyt/> and were known to cooperate with [[Lumumbism|Lumumbist]] factions in the Congo in the hopes of achieving future assistance against the Rwandan government.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=214}} However, the Congolese, Ugandan, and Tanganyikan governments were opposed to the radicalisation of the refugees, and tried to curb Inyenzi acitivity on their soil.{{sfn|Onoma|2013|p=204}} In February and March 1962 Inyenzi conducted two raids in the prefecture of Biumba, killing several Hutu policemen and civil servants. From 26–27 March the Hutu population of the prefecture retaliated by killing 1,000–2,000 Tutsi civilians, burning their homes, and looting their property.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=217, 219}}
 
Early UNAR Tutsi insurgent activity was confined to acts of terrorism against specific individuals and families. As more Tutsi refugees fled Rwanda, UNAR's exile ranks grew, and more systematic attempts were made to raise bands of combatants to launch raids on targeted areas. Violence in Rwanda dramatically increased as Tutsis fled ''en masse'' in early 1960; the first acts of violence were retaliatory attacks by Tutsis against Hutu officials who had mistreated them, but by early 1962 planned raids had become predominant. These were intended to inflict maximum damage to the Hutu-dominated administration and were generally conducted without consideration for government reprisals on local Tutsis.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=217}} By 1963, about 60,000 Tutsi refugees were living in the [[Republic of the Congo (Léopoldville)|Republic of the Congo]], 48,000 in Uganda, 25,000 in Burundi, and 16,000 in [[Tanganyika (1961–1964)|Tanganyika]].<ref name = nyt/> As the insurgents were known to attack at night, they were called Inyenzi, meaning "cockroaches". It is unknown whether the rebels themselves or officials of the Kayibanda regime coined the term. While later used in a derogatory sense against Tutsis generally, most contemporary sources refer to the exile rebels with the term in a non-pejorative fashion.{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=184}} Alternatively, the rebels called themselves Inkotanyi ("fighters/warriors"). As a result of the rivalries among the UNAR exile leadership and their geographic division, the insurgents were never able to adopt a cohesive strategy or unified command structure.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}} The [[People's Republic of China]] also provided the guerillas with training opportunities and financial support.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|pp=39–40}}{{efn|The People's Republic of China reportedly chose to support the rebels as a response to Kayibanda's denunciations of communism and his recognition of [[Chiang Kai-shek]]'s [[Taiwan|rival Chinese government]].<ref>{{cite news| last = Sulzberger| first = C. L.| title = Foreign Affairs: Prince Charlie and the Cockroaches| newspaper = The New York Times| page = 30| date = 6 April 1964}}</ref> The People's Republic of China reportedly provided US$ 120,000 to Kigeli and offered to train 10 Inyenzi in revolutionary tactics.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}} }} The Tutsi rebels reportedly also enlisted some defectors of the [[Armée Nationale Congolaise]] (National Congolese Army),<ref name = nyt/> and were known to cooperate with [[Lumumbism|Lumumbist]] factions in the Congo in the hopes of achieving future assistance against the Rwandan government.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=214}}{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}} However, the Congolese, Ugandan, and Tanganyikan governments were opposed to the radicalisation of the refugees, and tried to curb Inyenzi acitivityactivity on their soil.{{sfn|Onoma|2013|p=204}} In February and March 1962 Inyenzi conducted two raids in the prefecture of Biumba, killing several Hutu policemen and civil servants. From 26–2726 to 27 March the Hutu population of the prefecture retaliated by killing 1,000–2,000 Tutsi civilians, burning their homes, and looting their property.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=217, 219}}
 
PRAMEHUTUPARMEHUTU leaders had an exaggerated fear of the Inyenzi, believing they could count on the support of 10,000 exile recruits and forge links with domestic Tutsis. In reality, the UNAR exiles were factionalised and may have possible only numbered several hundred rebels.{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=185}} To counter the threat, the Rwandan government fielded a 1,000-strong{{sfn|Rosenberg et al.|2016|p=287}} [[Rwanda Defence Force|Garde Nationale Rwandaise]] (GNR, Rwandese National Guard),{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=220}} a force which was relatively poorly equipped{{sfn|Rosenberg et al.|2016|p=287}} and preoccupied with guarding Kigali and border outposts.<ref name= EAR/> Approximately 50 Belgian officers and subalterns aided it as ''coopérants techniques militaires'' (military technical assistants).<ref name= emmanuel/> Despite the military's weaknesses, researcher Simone Paulmichl argued that the even more poorly armed and less organised Inyenzi had no realistic chance of defeating the GNR by 1963.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|p=27}} According to researchers Tom Cooper and Adrien Fontanellaz, the GNR proved fairly effective in repelling Inyenzi attacks in the period leading up to the Bugesera invasion.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}}
 
== Prelude ==
{{See also|Burundi–Rwanda relations}}{{History of Rwanda}}
The decision to mount a large attack against Rwanda in late 1963 was made by UNAR leaders in Burundi that November.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=219}} In August communal elections had been held throughout Rwanda. PARMEHUTU won an overwhelming majority of the offices,<ref name= emmanuel/> but the campaign revealed significant internal disagreements in the party which allowed UNAR to consolidate its domestic support.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=219}} In October 1963 Kigeli gave $23,000—a portion of the money he had received from the Chinese government—to Papias Gatwa, his personal secretary, with instructions to pass it on to Rukeba, who was in the Congo at that moment.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=206}} This money enabled UNAR's exiled leaders to buy arms and ammunition.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=219}} There were rumours that Gatwa and Rukeba had actually embezzled the money given to them by Kigeli, and that Rukeba had ordered the subsequent attacks into Rwanda to "justify" the use of the funds.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=206}} According to journalist [[Linda Melvern]], the Inyenzi in Burundi also acquired arms with funds garnered by selling food provided by relief organisations to refugees.{{sfn|Melvern|2000|p=17}} The Inyenzi could rely upon a large amount of small arms seized from a police armoury in [[Ngara]], Tanganyika earlier in the year. By November, Rukeba's headquarters in Bujumbura had been able to establish effective communications between Tutsi refugee centres in Burundi and Tanzania. Academic [[René Lemarchand]] concluded, "if anyone can be said to bear responsibility for the raids that were launched from Burundi, it was Rukeba."{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=219}} Cooper and Fontanellaz argued that the decision for a large invasion, designed to win the conflict in one fell swoop, was motivated by the capture and execution of several rebel leaders in late 1963.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}}
 
In late November the Inyenzi in Burundi were weakened after Rukeba was arrested by local authorities, who discovered a cache of weapons in his home—purportedly stolen from Congolese rebels—and after the government seized three truckloads of arms near Bujumbura. The first attempt by the Inyenzi in Burundi to invade Rwanda came shortly thereafter on 25 November 1963. Approximately 1,500 refugees from across Burundi mostly armed with spears and bows and arrows, began making the three-day journey towards the Rwandan border. Upon learning of this, [[United Nations Commission on Human Rights]] (UNCHR) Representative in Bujumbura Jacques Cuenod and a group of Protestant missionaries alerted the Burundian government and frantically tried to persuade them to stop the attack. Cuenod pointed out that the GNR was probably waiting at the border for the Inyenzi and would certainly defeat them. After some hesitation, the Burundian government dispatched the gendarmerie to disarm the refugees and return them to their camps. One refugee later told UNCHR worker [[Francois Preziosi]] that Rukeba had ordered the attack after a meeting in Bujumbura during which Inyenzi leaders from other countries expressed their opposition. The refugee also stated that Kigeli had reportedly asked Rukeba not to launch any attacks in a letter.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=220}} However, researchers Günther Philipp and Helmut Strizek stated that the rebel force which invaded Rwanda in 1963 was ultimately commanded by Kigeli.{{sfn|Philipp|1978|p=1715}}{{sfn|Strizek|1996|p=156}}
 
In early December the attitude of the Burundian authorities towards forestalling Inyenzi attacks on Rwanda changed, as a meeting between Rwandan and Burundian delegates in [[Gisenyi]] to resolve outstanding issues regarding the dissolution of the Rwanda-Burundi monetary and customs union fell apart due to disagreements. Burundian Vice Prime Minister [[Pié Masumbuko]] told a Rwandan official, "Recently we have arrested people who were about to attack you and now you decide to sever economic relations with us. Therefore you do not want collaboration."{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=221}}
Line 64 ⟶ 68:
}}
 
On 21 December 1963 the Inyenzi initiated a better-coordinated invasion attempt.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=220}} The insurgents reportedly called their force the "Armée Royale Rwandaise" (Royal Rwandese Army).{{sfn|Philipp|1978|p=1715}}{{sfn|Strizek|1996|p=156}} According to "reliable sources", Inyenzi leaders hoped to orchestrate simultaneous attacks on Rwanda from four different regions: Kabare, Uganda; Ngara, Tanganyika; [[Goma]], Congo; and Ngozi and Kayanza, Burundi.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=220}} At 04:30 that day 200–300 Inyenzi mostly armed with [[Improvised firearm|hand-made rifles]], spears and arrows, crossed the Burundian border at [[Nemba]].{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=222}} As they progressed through the country the Inyenzi were joined by local Tutsis, growing to a size of about 600.{{sfn|Melvern|2000|p=17}} About an hour later they overran the Rwandan military in camp in Gako, [[Kabuga]], [[Bugesera District|Bugesera]].{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=222}} After ladening themselves with captured arms and ammunition{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=185}} and taking two jeeps,<ref name= EAR/> they went to the Tutsi displaced persons camp at [[Nyamata]], where they were joyously received by the locals. According to some observers, the Inyenzi wasted their time by celebrating and drinking alcohol.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=222–223}} With their ranks now having grown to 1,000–7,000, the Inyenzi force proceeded towards Kigali.{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=185}}
 
Aaron Segal wrote that Rwandan leaders initially panicked when faced with invasion, fearing a multi-pronged attack supported by Burundi to restore the monarchy.{{sfn|Straus|2013|pp=185–186}}{{sfn|Segal|1964|p=13}} In contrast, historian Dantès Singiza wrote that Major Camille Tulpin—a Belgian military adviser and the ''de facto'' head of the [[Sûreté]] Nationale Rwandaise—and leaders of the GNR had become informed of the Inyenzi's plans beforehand and aimed to draw them into an ambush.<ref name= singiza>{{cite web| url = https://archives.africamuseum.be/agents/people/1333| title = Tulpin, Camille| last = Singiza| first = Dantès | website = AfricaMuseum Archives| publisher = [[Royal Museum for Central Africa]]| language = French| access-date = 15 June 2021}}</ref> According to François-Xavier Munyarugerero and military historian [[Frank Rusagara]], Lieutenant [[Juvénal Habyarimana]]—the commander of the GNR—organised the government counter-offensive.{{sfn|Munyarugerero|2003|p=114}}{{sfn|Rusagara|2009|pp=157–158}} Conversely, Segal wrote that the commander handed control over to a Belgian military adviser, who rallied the Garde to stop the incursion.{{sfn|Segal|1964|p=13}} The Inyenzi were stopped {{convert|12 miles (19 kilometres)|mi|km|abbr=off}} south of the city at Kanzenze Bridge along the [[Nyabarongo River]] by multiple units of the GNR led by Belgian officers and equipped with mortars and semi-automatic weapons.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=223}} The Belgian officers who were most involved included Commandant Frans, Captain Dubois, and [[Chief warrant officer|Chief Adjutant]] Florquin. Among the leading Rwandans involved were Second Lieutenant Ruhashya and Second Lieutenant Mbonampeka as well as cadets from the Rwandan officers' school in Butare.{{sfn|Munyarugerero|2003|pp=114–115}} In the ensuing battle the Inyenzi were defeated by the GNR's superior firepower, with several hundred Tutsis and several Congolese killed. It was reported that on one of the bodies of the Congolese the GNR found the Inyenzi's invasion plans and a list of ministers they wished to install upon overthrowing the government.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=223}} Tulpin accused domestic UNAR politicians of knowing about the document.{{sfn|Munyarugerero|2003|p=115}} The Inyenzi survivors fled towards the Burundian border.<ref name = nyt/> According to Segal, four Rwandan soldiers were killed in the fighting at Gako.<ref name= EAR/> ''The New York Times'' reported that the Inyenzi executed four Rwandan soldiers they had captured as they retreated.<ref name = nyt/> According to Cooper and Fontanellaz, the Inyenzi retreat was covered by snipers who killed two GNR soldiers, and the rebels killed seven prisoners once back in Burundi.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=UNAR insurgency}}
 
From 21–2221 to 22 December several small raids were launched by Inyenzi operating from [[Kivu]], Congo across the Ruzizi plain towards [[Cyangugu]]. The GNR rebuffed them and executed about 90 prisoners. From Uganda, one group of Inyenzi led by Kibibiro attempted to reach the Rwandan border but was stopped by the local authorities on 25 December. Two days later about 600 Inyenzi crossed into Rwanda at Kizinga.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=222}} Armed mostly with spears, bows, and machetes, they attacked [[Nyagatare]].<ref name = nyt/> The GNR was alert for further incursions<ref name= EAR/> and thus the Inyenzi were almost immediately{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=222}} repelled by 110 GNR soldiers armed with [[semi-automatic rifle]]s.<ref name = nyt/> The insurgents suffered 300 dead.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=40}}<ref name = nyt/> The survivors fled back into Uganda, where they were captured or killed by a company of the [[Uganda Army (1962–1971)|Uganda Rifles]].<ref name= EAR/>{{efn|While the Inyenzi had initially cultivated support in Uganda through Tutsi refugee communities and the sympathies of the government of the subnational Kingdom of [[Buganda]], Ugandan Prime Minister [[Milton Obote]] and his government cracked down on their efforts, as he distrusted Buganda authorities and sought to avoid increasing tensions with neighbouring states.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=206–207}}}} The attacks from Tanganyika never occurred.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=222}}
 
== Repression and atrocities ==
Line 86 ⟶ 90:
[[File:Africa addio (1966) - Rwandan revolution 1.png|thumb|right|Bloodied tree stump used by Hutu militias to cut off the hands of Tutsis.]]
 
In its first reports on the killings, [[Radio Rwanda]], the state broadcaster, stated that 750 people had been killed{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=224}}—350 Inyenzi during their attack and 400 civilians.{{sfn|Melvern|2000|p=18}} The Rwandan government later issued a [[white paper]] in March 1964 which listed 870 deaths. Lemarchand characterised these figures as "patently inaccurate"{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=224, 226}} and estimated that at least 10,000 Tutsis died in the reprisals.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=216}} The UN estimated 1,000–3,000 deaths,{{sfn|Melvern|2000|p=18}} while the [[World Council of Churches]] suggested that between 10,000–14000 and 14,000 Tutsis were killed.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=216}} Estimates of the death toll of civilians in the repression reach as high as 20,000.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=40}} Lemarchand argued that determining the precise number of casualties was "impossible".{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=224}}
 
=== Public criticism and response ===
Line 103 ⟶ 107:
 
[[File:Africa addio (1966) - Rwandan revolution 13.png|thumb|Tutsi refugees fleeing to Uganda with their cattle in January 1964]]
Politically, the invasion and subsequent reprisals boosted the popular support of the Rwandan government{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=227}} and heightened the status of the GNR.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=41}} Kayibanda was able to portray himself as the [[Father of the Nation]] and champion of the poor Hutu peasants, claiming to defend their hard-won gains of the revolution against the Tutsis who wanted to restore the oppressive feudalism of the old monarchy.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|p=28}} UNAR's domestic bases of support were destroyed.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=227}} Rwanda became a ''de facto'' one-party state and the military improved its organisation.{{sfn|Straus|2013|pp=188–189}} While some refugees returned in April as the situation calmed,{{sfn|Brecher|Wilkenfeld|1997|p=442}} the Rwandan Tutsi exile population dramatically increased as a result of the massacres, tripling from 120,000 in 1962 to 336,000 in 1964.{{sfn|Carney|2014|p=179}} By late 1964 UNAR's government-in-exile, undermined by internal disagreement and disorganisation, had mostly ceased to exist.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|pp=204–205}} It was succeeded by a number of splinter groups which further declined in the following years.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|loc=Slaughter}} PARMEHUTU won all seats in the Legislative Assembly during the 1965 elections.<ref name= emmanuel/> Nkeramugaba launched a candidacy for a seat that year and won an overwhelming majority of the votes in Gikongoro.{{sfn|Lemarchand|1970|p=226}} Foreign-based Inyenzi attacks continued until 1966 but were easily repelled.{{sfn|Waugh|2013|p=28}}{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=189}} Kayibanda's regime imposed ethnic quotas based on proportional representation, thus allowing Tutsis to occupy nine percent of civil service positions, but they were excluded from the political sphere.{{sfn|Stapleton|2017|p=42}} Despite this, Tutsis remained disproportionately represented in the country's higher education system, a fact which continued to generate resentment among Hutus.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|p=29}} The country remained free of large-scale ethnic violence until 1973{{sfn|Straus|2013|p=189}} when new purges against Tutsis and inter-Hutu violence resulted in the overthrow of Kayibanda's regime.{{sfn|Paulmichl|1998|p=29}}
 
=== Regional impact ===
Line 123 ⟶ 127:
* {{cite book| last1 = Brecher| first1 = Michael| last2 = Wilkenfeld| first2 = Jonathan| title = A Study of Crisis| publisher = University of Michigan Press| date = 1997| location =| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=GjY7aV_6FPwC| isbn = 9780472108060}}
* {{cite book| last = Carney| first = J.J.| title = Rwanda Before the Genocide: Catholic Politics and Ethnic Discourse in the Late Colonial Era| publisher = Oxford University Press USA| date = 2014| location =| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=IawzAAAAQBAJ| isbn = 9780199982271}}
* {{cite book| last1 = Cooper| first1 = Tom| last2 = Fontanellaz| first2 = Adrien| title = The Rwandan Patriotic Front| publisher = Helion & Company| date = 2015| location = Solihull| isbn = 9781910294567}}
* {{cite book| last = Harroy| first = Jean-Paul |author-link= Jean-Paul Harroy| title = Rwanda: souvenirs d'un compagnon de la marche du Rwanda vers la démocratie et l'indépendance|trans-title= Rwanda: memories of a companion of Rwanda's march towards democracy and independence| publisher = Hayez| edition = 2nd| date = 1989| location =| language = French| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=vKYPAQAAMAAJ| isbn = 9782871260073}}
* {{cite book| last = Lemarchand| first = René| title = Rwanda and Burundi| publisher = Praeger Publishers| date = 1970| location = New York| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=n4UZAAAAMAAJ| oclc = 254366212}}
Line 131 ⟶ 136:
* {{cite book| last = Mushemeza| first = Elijah Dickens| title = The Politics and Empowerment of Banyarwanda Refugees in Uganda, 1959-2001| publisher = Fountain Publishers| date = 2007| location = Kampala| isbn = 9789970027194}}
* {{cite book |last=Onoma |first=Ato Kwamena |year=2013 |title=Anti-Refugee Violence and African Politics |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=iUyyAAAAQBAJ |location=Cambridge |publisher=Cambridge University Press| isbn = 978-1-107-03669-7}}
* {{cite paperjournal|last = Paulmichl|first = Simone| title = Die Determinante des Völkermordes in Ruanda: Ethnizität als politische Waffe | journal = Arbeitspapiere zu Problemen der Internationalen Politik und der Entwicklungsländerforschung|trans-title=The Determinant of the Genocide in Rwanda: Ethnicity as a Political Weapon|issue=26| publisher = Geschwister-Scholl-Institut für Politikwissenschaft ([[Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich]]) | date = 1998 |language = German| url = https://www.gsi.uni-muenchen.de/forschung/forsch_zentr/forschung_3_welt/arbeitspapier/ap26.pdf |issn= 1430-6794}}
* {{cite book |last=Philipp |first=Günther |chapter=Rwanda |editor-last1= Sternberger|editor-first1= Dolf |editor-last2= Vogel|editor-first2= Bernhard |editor-last3= Nohlen|editor-first3= Dieter |editor-last4= Landfried|editor-first4= Klaus |title=Afrika: Politische Organisation und Repräsentation in Afrika |publisher= De Gruyter|pages= 1691–1730 |date= 1978|chapter-url= |location= Berlin |language = German|isbn= 9783110904802|url= https://books.google.com/books?id=nlG9DwAAQBAJ}}
* {{cite book| editor-last1 = Rosenberg| editor-first1 = Sheri P.| editor-last2 = Galis| editor-first2 = Tibi| editor-last3 = Zucker| editor-first3 = Alex| title = Reconstructing Atrocity Prevention| publisher = Cambridge University Press| date = 2016| location =| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=H56NCgAAQBAJ| isbn = 9781107094963| ref = {{harvid|Rosenberg et al.|2016}}}}
Line 143 ⟶ 148:
* {{cite book| last = Waugh| first = Colin M.| title = Paul Kagame and Rwanda: Power, Genocide and the Rwandan Patriotic Front| publisher = McFarland| date = 2013| location =| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=a82JCYuEdMAC| isbn = 9781476613154 }}
* {{cite book| last = Weinstein| first = Warren| title = Historical Dictionary of Burundi| publisher = Scarecrow Press| date = 1976| location = Metuchen| isbn = 978-0-8108-0962-8}}
{{refend}}{{Rwanda topics}}
 
[[Category:Civil wars involving the states and peoples of Africa]]
[[Category:Civil wars post-1945of the 20th century]]
[[Category:Ethnicity-based civil wars]]
[[Category:Conflicts in 1963]]
[[Category:Wars involving Rwanda]]
[[Category:Political history of Rwanda]]
[[Category:1963 in Rwanda]]
[[Category:Massacres in Rwanda]]
[[Category:20th-century mass murder in Africa]]
[[Category:Political repressionand cultural purges]]
[[Category:Burundi–Rwanda relations]]
[[Category:Cross-border operations]]