Dave's Reviews > 1984

1984 by George Orwell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
228754
's review

it was amazing

In George Orwell's 1984, Winston Smith is an open source developer who writes his code offline because his ISP has installed packet sniffers that are regulated by the government under the Patriot Act. It's really for his own protection, though. From, like, terrorists and DVD pirates and stuff. Like every good American, he drinks Coca-Cola and his processed food has desensitized his palate to all but four flavors: sweet, salty-so-that-you-will-drink-more-coca-cola, sweet, and Cooler Ranch!(tm). His benevolent overlords have provided him with some war happening somewhere for some reason so that he, and the rest of the population, can be sure that the government is really in his best interests. In fact, the news always has some story about Paris Hilton or yet another white girl who has been abducted by some evil bastard who is biologically wired by 200,000 years of human evolution to fuck 12-year-olds, but is socially conditioned to be obsessed with sex, yet also to feel guilty about it. This culminates into a distorted view of sexuality, and results in rape and murder, which both make for very good news topics. This, too, is in Winston's best interests because, while fear is healthy, thinking *too* much about his own mortality is strictly taboo, as it may lead to something dangerously insightful, and he might lose his taste for Coca Cola and breast implants. The television also plays on his fears of the unknown by exaggerating stereotypes of minorities and homosexuals, under the guise of celebrating "diversity", but even these images of being ghetto-fabulous and a lisping interior designer actually exist solely to promote racism and homophobia, which also prove to be efficient distractions.

For some reason, Winston gets tired of eating recycled Pop Tarts and eating happy pills and pretending to be interested in sports and manufactured news items. But, in the end, they fix him and he's happy again. Or something.
2550 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read 1984.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
July 28, 2007 – Shelved

Comments Showing 51-100 of 166 (166 new)


Juston The best review of my life.


message 52: by Susy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susy Best.Review.Ever?


message 53: by Adam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Adam I read this book years ago, but was inspired to comment by the lively debate that has occured here over the last 5 years.

So here's my two cents. Just like a utopia, a dystopia needs to draw from the world around it to make the work relevant. 1984 is a great example of this type of story because of how sucessful it was at predicting the future. When we look at these works we see more of what fits than doesn't and that's where I think a lot of people trip themselves up in analyzing this book.

P.S. We, 1984 and BNW, all explore topics as rekecant today as they were the days they were published. I truly love and cherish all three of these books... but if I had to pick just one I'd go with BNW b/c it has by far the most "entertaining" story


J-Reads You sir are a Champion among mere mortals.


message 55: by 苗苗 (new) - added it

苗苗 曹 Nice review!


Marco Haha well said, good review.


message 57: by Dale (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dale Pearl Dave I think you hit the nail on the head. If you do not respond to this message I will know that big brother has already dealt with you. Sad how just about everything in this book is now reality. Almost as if American politicians read this book in the early 50's and made it a checklist to implement.


Prashant Ghabak The best review I have read!


Victoria Wilde Most excellent review.


Chollie You ever thought of taking up the pen yerself-:->)


Bryan Reading your review made me laugh so hard my eyes started watering. Thanks for that :)


Nadia one comment: Winston is in London and the last time I looked at a map it was in the UK NOT the USA!


Victoria Wilde I think you may have missed the point, Nadia.


Aliya haha.
10/0


Mihaita George Eoin wrote: "Eoin Dave, have you actually read 1984? Modern day America is nothing like Oceania."

WAR IS PEACE.
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY.
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH.

And the Strength is strong in this one


Conor Yo sup add me nigga


Conor Good comment. Good name. Approve


Caryarit Ferrer this review is so great


Sebastian Ekberg By describing, what in many ways is the common American life, you are able to show why Orwell’s dystopia has come to life. The parallels between Oceania and modern America is not only clear, but also extremely frightening when you start scratching the surface. I agree to your view, that the fictitious world of 1984 and our society have a lot in common and I appreciate that you took some time the compose this amusing review. The review by itself doesn’t give away anything about the actual story, but it clarifies the underlying message in a creative way. Well done!


message 70: by Kumari (new) - added it

Kumari Thank you for this review. I found as I was contemplating my own review and thought of what I learned from _1984_. How is it different from today or how could it be written about today, commenting on the status quo of today, while projecting it in the future.

Your review answered my questions, by putting it altogether - all the shit that we experience over time that makes you cringe, but then your attention is summarily moved onto the next "catastrophe" the news wants to distract you with, so you never have time to think it all the way, though. Nor is it possible to pick a favorite cause to fight against because there are so many that it's overwhelming. Perhaps It's not the government holding us all back and in, but its the greed of the corporations who control the politicians. The worst is that its the people in our society and their insecurity and general sheepishness that makes it all stick. Social control comes from the people around you, who give the power to the government and give the money to the corporations, who in turn tell them what to do and the idiots do it with a smile on their faces because they wouldnt know what to do otherwise. Look at 1984, it was his neighbors who kept him most in line who he had the most to fear bc they had so completely bought into the system that they'd become unpaid spies, with a mission to keep everyone in line, lest it upset their own meager since of security.


message 71: by William (new)

William Kerfoot You're a fucking idiot!


Chris Heestand Pretty much.


Aiden Exactly.


message 74: by Juan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Juan Talamante Está suave


Rosamond But I must say, we aren't quite there. This is worthy of being turned into a movie if we added the debate about how the govt still does allow free speech, hackers like Assange, and stuff like that.


Milan This is an English book, not American


message 77: by bg (new) - rated it 5 stars

bg couldn't have said it better!


message 78: by Michaela (new)

Michaela Starr Why are people continuously pointing out that it's a British novel as if that someone detracts from the point of this review? The mark of great literature is that it transcends geography and time and resonates with people across the board. Just because it was set in London doesn't mean parallels can't be drawn between some of the ideas and present day USA


message 79: by Dale (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dale Pearl I agree


Angie We seem more headed toward the Corpocracy described in Cloud Atlas (not a classic, but I just finished it). The Patriot Act is unnerving when one thinks about 1984, though.


message 81: by Azra (new) - rated it 5 stars

Azra This is an awesome review!


message 82: by Azra (new) - rated it 5 stars

Azra This is an awesome review!


Sangeet Thapa Nice point of view


WarpDrive Great review, Dave. Dave. Certainly the mass international spying activities by the NSA have a strong Orwellian flavour. I would like to add some new words to the Orwellian newspeak: "weapons of mass destruction", "regime change", "war on terror


Nikolaos Kantanas I love this review.


Dwayne Wow! This all sounds so hauntingly familiar.


message 87: by El (new) - rated it 4 stars

El Nick nice review. but you failed to mention his nasty habit of doing it to Julia!


Alejandro Colon Nice!


Fatima :)))


message 90: by Etah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Etah This review definitely made me smile! Great job


message 91: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John Dude --I believe you have written the best review on Goodreads. I am sure Orwell would be amused with your update and disturbed that it's not satire.


J. Yates Right on brother!!


message 93: by Charles (new)

Charles Vella Great review. I laughed out loud.


message 94: by [deleted user] (new)

Perfect review! :-)


Fatma Koriem Wherever you live ,whatever kind of governing authorities, religious or secular, democratic or totalitarian, There will be fundamental Orwellian characteristics that control your life ,but don't worry all that effort is just for your own good even if you don't know yet :-)


message 96: by Dori (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dori Sharp The state of Oklahoma has banned AP U.S. History high school classes because they do not preach "American exceptionalism." Hmmm...


message 97: by Rivkasilver (new) - added it

Rivkasilver You sir, are really smart.
I love this


message 98: by [deleted user] (new)

I recently created a book project for 1984 for my 7th grade class and I feel like you accurately created this comment if this happened now but it is so different from the amazing book that is 1984 it is a book that makes you think, which differs from most current young adult literature. I understand that this is your view and opinion on this book but it could be portrayed differently and more accurately.


message 99: by [deleted user] (new)

You should be in charge of stuff.


message 100: by [deleted user] (last edited Jul 04, 2015 06:22AM) (new)

Eoin wrote: "Dave, have you actually read 1984? Modern day America is nothing like Oceania. Even if America were really as you describe it, it would still be nothing like Orwell’s dystopia. This should be obvious from the very fact that anyone can go online and post what you have posted for all to read and freely comment on. This is pretty much the exact opposite of how things work in 1984....."

Well, now that the government has gained control of the Internet (its regulatory agency), what you're allowed to say may indeed become limited.


back to top