If an object isn't specified in a <mapframe/>, an OSM relation could be automatically pulled from Wikidata (property P402) by using the Wikidata ID of the page, with an option to turn this off.
Description
Status | Subtype | Assigned | Task | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Resolved | None | T145171 <maplink/frame> without lat/long should use coordinates from Wikidata | |||
Declined | None | T145284 Allow Wikidata's P402 (OpenStreetMap Relation identifier) to be used in Kartographer |
Event Timeline
Please, don't use Property P402 !!!
We show it on WIWOSM [1] project that we don't need it to link from Kartographer to an geometry in OSM.
We can use Wikipedia and Wikidata-Tags in OSM and are so more flexible to suport also points and lines without and relation-id. The relation ID's in OSM are not stable.
so please change Kartograher to support OSM data without P402.
[1]https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/WIWOSM
We can't use OSM ids because they're not guaranteed to be stable, unlike Wikidata ids. We already have integration the other way around - with OSM's wikidata tag and will continue improving it.
If https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P402 is unstable, we should delete that.
I agree that it's not necessary to have the same information in both OSM and Wikidata, especially where P402 is (slightly) more likely to become inaccurate (e.g. when a transport service is deleted because it no longer exists and Wikidata isn't updated). I've started a deletion discussion here.
@Liuxinyu970226, please don't hijack this ticket and especially don't remove tags that are obvioulsy relevant. Feel free to create a separate ticket for the community wishlist item.