What do you think?
Rate this book
Safiyyah's War
Inspired by the true story of how the Grand Mosque of Paris saved the lives of hundreds of Jews during World War II, Hiba Noor Khan weaves a breathtaking tale of suspense, compassion, and courage, starring an extraordinary young heroine readers will never forget. Safiyyah loathes the brutal Nazi occupation of Paris, even though her Muslim identity keeps her safe—or, at least, safer than her Jewish neighbors. Violence lurks in the streets, her best friend has fled, and even her place of refuge—the library—has turned shadowy and confusing, as the invaders fear the power of books. Safiyyah longs to fight back and hates feeling powerless to help her Jewish friends. Worse yet, her father—who taught her to always do the right thing—is acting strangely and doing nothing to help them either. Or is he? Unravelling the mystery of her father’s odd behavior draws Safiyyah deep in the heart of the perilous underground resistance to the Nazis, where her bravery is put to the ultimate test…
336 pages, Hardcover
First published July 6, 2023
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 170 reviews
July 30, 2023
Equal parts exciting, emotional and educational, Saffiyah’s War is undoubtedly one of the best children’s books I’ve read so far in 2023. This is a story I would just as happily and eagerly recommend to adults as well as children. I am now incredibly excited to see what Hiba Noor Khan writes next because if this is anything to go by, she’s going to be a powerhouse in the world of children’s historical fiction.
April 2, 2024
During the second world war, the Grand Mosque of Paris saved 1700 Jews. How did I, a Jew whose family was decimated by the war, never know about this? The answer presumably has its roots in secrets and later tensions, but what's important is that Hiba Noor Khan is telling it now, so that children can know. It's more important than ever that we all see that we are sister cultures, especially as the generation who lived during the war are almost all gone.
Khan's writing is strong, warm, and evocative, equally suited to a middle grade readership and adults; in fact, this is a particularly good classroom book. She never avoids the trauma Safiyyah and the others are going through, even acknowledging the plight of abandoned pets, but the book also never feels hopeless.
That's the greatest gift this novel offers: hope. As Leonard Cohen said, "there's a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in." This book is about finding those cracks and helping to show their light to others.
May we all find peace.
Khan's writing is strong, warm, and evocative, equally suited to a middle grade readership and adults; in fact, this is a particularly good classroom book. She never avoids the trauma Safiyyah and the others are going through, even acknowledging the plight of abandoned pets, but the book also never feels hopeless.
That's the greatest gift this novel offers: hope. As Leonard Cohen said, "there's a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in." This book is about finding those cracks and helping to show their light to others.
May we all find peace.
April 26, 2023
Safiyyah’s War by Hiba Noor Kahn
Madame Odette never asked unnecessary questions when Sufiyyah asked to see the maps in the library. She would just lead Sufiyyah through to the world section, unroll the maps for her and take out a few leather-bound books that could be helpful. Then Sufiyyah would marvel at the maps, tracing the lines, ‘whispering the names of the towns, cities, islands and lagoons – like secrets, feeling a thirst for the world.’ Sufiyya’s plan was to be an explorer. Getting lost in the world section of the library, sometimes, she forgot the time and, since the rumour of war was getting ever closer, faced her worried mother’s wrath for getting home late. She knew her mother was only concerned – but she wished she would relax. Nothing had changed at school or on the streets of Paris for Sufiyya, she felt no fear, there were no bombs. But on her way home one day, desperate to tell Setti, her grandmother, what she had discovered she sees a grown man holding the hand of a small child openly crying. This was the start of seeing things that would change her, her friends, neighbours, Paris and the mosque where her family lived for ever.
Hiba has told this story in such a way that it invites you into a world that few of us have ever even heard of let alone entered then completely envelopes you in sights, sounds, smells, emotions that draw you into Sufiyya’s experience of World War Two. Many books have told stories from this time in history but the Muslims in Paris and the way they used their Mosque has all but been forgotten by historians. Their bravery, compassion and creativity saved so many lives.
Powerful and sensitive, this story doesn’t just deal with the big, terrifying, brutal acts of war – but with the tender, desperate, intimate acts that speak with such a thundering voice of how deeply the effects penetrate… I am grateful every day for the accident of my place of birth which means I have never experienced war – this book compounds that feeling.
‘A children’s story that can only be enjoyed by children is not a good children’s story in the slightest’ as C S Lewis said and this and this story should most definitely not only be read by children.
Published in July 2023 by Anderson Press
Madame Odette never asked unnecessary questions when Sufiyyah asked to see the maps in the library. She would just lead Sufiyyah through to the world section, unroll the maps for her and take out a few leather-bound books that could be helpful. Then Sufiyyah would marvel at the maps, tracing the lines, ‘whispering the names of the towns, cities, islands and lagoons – like secrets, feeling a thirst for the world.’ Sufiyya’s plan was to be an explorer. Getting lost in the world section of the library, sometimes, she forgot the time and, since the rumour of war was getting ever closer, faced her worried mother’s wrath for getting home late. She knew her mother was only concerned – but she wished she would relax. Nothing had changed at school or on the streets of Paris for Sufiyya, she felt no fear, there were no bombs. But on her way home one day, desperate to tell Setti, her grandmother, what she had discovered she sees a grown man holding the hand of a small child openly crying. This was the start of seeing things that would change her, her friends, neighbours, Paris and the mosque where her family lived for ever.
Hiba has told this story in such a way that it invites you into a world that few of us have ever even heard of let alone entered then completely envelopes you in sights, sounds, smells, emotions that draw you into Sufiyya’s experience of World War Two. Many books have told stories from this time in history but the Muslims in Paris and the way they used their Mosque has all but been forgotten by historians. Their bravery, compassion and creativity saved so many lives.
Powerful and sensitive, this story doesn’t just deal with the big, terrifying, brutal acts of war – but with the tender, desperate, intimate acts that speak with such a thundering voice of how deeply the effects penetrate… I am grateful every day for the accident of my place of birth which means I have never experienced war – this book compounds that feeling.
‘A children’s story that can only be enjoyed by children is not a good children’s story in the slightest’ as C S Lewis said and this and this story should most definitely not only be read by children.
Published in July 2023 by Anderson Press
March 21, 2023
I found this book fascinating as I hadn’t heard about the Great Mosque in France before and was unaware of the role it played in the resistance. I think every class should have a copy of this book as it’s so important in so many ways. First to provide representation; for children to see that it people of many different races took a stand against the Nazis and secondly because of the message of respect towards other religions that this book shows. There can be such a focus on the things that make us different and such negative representation of people of different religions and the courageous acts of the people in this book (and the real life people it’s based on) show that what really matters is love and respect, especially in the face of hatred. The characters are all so brave and do what is right, even though it’s scary and hard. I think the world would be a better place if more people were like Safiyyah and her family and I hope, if I was ever in a similar situation I would have the courage to be as brave as her.
May 13, 2024
This was a very moving middle grade book based on the real life events of Muslims at the Grand Mosque of Paris harbouring Jewish people and shepherding them to safety during WW2. Safiyyah was a very bright and brave young girl deeply feeling the injustices and perils of war and working with the French Resistance.
The cover art is gorgeous too.
A lovely book of tolerance and humanity.
The cover art is gorgeous too.
A lovely book of tolerance and humanity.
March 27, 2024
Loved this so much!! Middle grade is such a great way to introduce difficult topics in an accessible way, and this book handled that perfectly. On the slightly older side of the bracket, this book didn't shy away from clearly showing how difficult the German occupation in Paris was and the extremes that were taken against Jews. I had no idea about this hidden story - that the Grand Mosque of Paris offered refuge and aided in smuggling out hundreds of Jews using the underground passages. It's such a fascinating read! The main character, Safiyyah, was so loveable, and her bravery and determination were admirable. The importance of keeping your friends and family close in difficult times was clearly highlighted, and Safiyyah's relationships with all her family members were so heartwarming to read about, especially with Setti, her grandma.
June 17, 2023
I tend to avoid 'WW2 in Britain/France' books, because I find them very samey and consider the time period overall very overdone - but apparently adding a Muslim character is the way to get me to read one, and this was wonderful!
Safiyyah was such a brilliant heroine - she's so brave and bold and curious, and Hiba Noor Khan does such a great job of capturing a child's perspective, balancing an eleven year old's worldview with the upheaval having to grow up too fast in wartime. Her relationship with her family was also so lovely, especially her grandmother (though I also wanted to know more about the family's history! Why did they move from Algeria to Spain, and then to France?)
Though I've been to the Grand Mosque of Paris, I had no idea about its history helping Jews escape the Holocaust. I love that it's the characters' foundation of faith that makes them so determined to do the right thing (we often hear about Catholic priests etc. who sheltered Jews in WW2, so I love that we get this version of that story too!), and I really appreciated how naturally Islam was woven into the story.
Ultimately this is a story about love and kindness, and doing the right thing even when it would be easier not to. Certain lines definitely felt very pointedly applicable to present day issues, but overall I love the message that this sends for both children and adult readers! Actually, this is exactly the kind of book I want adults who dismiss middle grade to read, because the writing may be simple, but that doesn't mean it's not effective, and the way Khan writes emotions is incredibly moving!
Thank you to NetGalley and Andersen Press for a copy in exchange for an honest review.
CW: antisemitism, Holocaust, PTSD, family separation, grief
Safiyyah was such a brilliant heroine - she's so brave and bold and curious, and Hiba Noor Khan does such a great job of capturing a child's perspective, balancing an eleven year old's worldview with the upheaval having to grow up too fast in wartime. Her relationship with her family was also so lovely, especially her grandmother (though I also wanted to know more about the family's history! Why did they move from Algeria to Spain, and then to France?)
Though I've been to the Grand Mosque of Paris, I had no idea about its history helping Jews escape the Holocaust. I love that it's the characters' foundation of faith that makes them so determined to do the right thing (we often hear about Catholic priests etc. who sheltered Jews in WW2, so I love that we get this version of that story too!), and I really appreciated how naturally Islam was woven into the story.
Ultimately this is a story about love and kindness, and doing the right thing even when it would be easier not to. Certain lines definitely felt very pointedly applicable to present day issues, but overall I love the message that this sends for both children and adult readers! Actually, this is exactly the kind of book I want adults who dismiss middle grade to read, because the writing may be simple, but that doesn't mean it's not effective, and the way Khan writes emotions is incredibly moving!
Thank you to NetGalley and Andersen Press for a copy in exchange for an honest review.
CW: antisemitism, Holocaust, PTSD, family separation, grief
February 1, 2024
This children’s novel is a great addition to the historical fiction genre. Specifically, Hiba Noor Khan shines a light on the Muslim perspective in Paris during World War II.
Khan’s book is inspired by the events of the Nazi occupation and how the Grand Mosque of Paris saved lives of hundreds of Jews at the time.
This book elicits feelings of terror and fear, as well as compassion and courage. Young people and adults will enjoy this novel.
Thank you #NetGalley and Harper Collins for the ARC!
Khan’s book is inspired by the events of the Nazi occupation and how the Grand Mosque of Paris saved lives of hundreds of Jews at the time.
This book elicits feelings of terror and fear, as well as compassion and courage. Young people and adults will enjoy this novel.
Thank you #NetGalley and Harper Collins for the ARC!
Read
February 27, 2023A beautiful and touching about bravery, resistance and family by an extraordinary new voice in children's fiction. A must-read!
September 10, 2023
4.5*
"Ah, but you see, dear child, oppressors always fear the power of books"
"Ah, but you see, dear child, oppressors always fear the power of books"
July 8, 2024
This is such a unique and intriguing WWII story that I had never heard about! Inspired by true events, this book centers around Safiyyah and her family, Muslims who live and work at the Grand Mosque in Paris, and their efforts to save Jews from the Nazis during the war. Safiyyah is kind-hearted and intelligent, curious and impulsive, and loves maps. I quickly fell in love. with her whole family and her friends as they follow the tenets of their faith, showing kindness to others and honoring God. Safiyyah's relationship with her grandmother is especially poignant. While some parts of the book feel almost slice-of-life, it all comes together in a rather suspenseful climax.
I love finding lesser-known stories from WWII. Those years truly affected the entire world, and right now is an excellent time to learn from our past to prevent even worse events in our future. Safiyyah's War is a beautiful story of community, faith, compassion, and doing what is right.
I love finding lesser-known stories from WWII. Those years truly affected the entire world, and right now is an excellent time to learn from our past to prevent even worse events in our future. Safiyyah's War is a beautiful story of community, faith, compassion, and doing what is right.
September 5, 2024
Fascinating and beautifully told! I read aloud with my son. Having visited the Grande mosquée and tea room many times I could visualize this book well. I'm grateful to the author for bringing to light this important, little known story of the Resistance from the Muslim community in Paris to save hundreds of Jewish people during Nazi occupation.
October 22, 2023
I thought this was a really great book! All about a group of Muslims who were helping Jewish people to escape Paris via their Mosque and the catacombs which run underneath it.
The main character, Saffiyah, finds herself having to grow up very fast when war is declared. When hoards of people start to leave Paris, and her father begins to behave mysteriously, Saffiyah is determined to find out what is going on. With lots of twists and turns and an interesting insight into true events. I know that this will be a great book to add to the school Library & to our classroom book clubs.
The main character, Saffiyah, finds herself having to grow up very fast when war is declared. When hoards of people start to leave Paris, and her father begins to behave mysteriously, Saffiyah is determined to find out what is going on. With lots of twists and turns and an interesting insight into true events. I know that this will be a great book to add to the school Library & to our classroom book clubs.
August 6, 2023
Everyone should read this book!!
August 16, 2024
I am ever so glad I found this by chance whilst browsing in my local bookshop. To think it initially caught my eye because the name in its title reminded me of a friend of mine, and the lovely illustrations on the cover. It turns out that 'Safiyyah's War' is just as great - no, better by far - as its cover suggests.
'Safiyyah's War' is a new children's book about World War II. It is based around a true life heroic story - a different, widely forgotten and erased part of history I certainly never heard of before: about how Muslims in Paris hid Jews in their mosques, as a sanctuary and refuge, and helped them escape the Nazi occupation; through the Resistance, involving secret messengers, underground tunnels, catacombs, and boats on rivers, under the cover of night.
It is a true testament to humans' limitless capacity to love, and to be compassionate, empathetic, and brave, and to preserve our spirit, no matter what tragedies befall us. We are each so much braver, and more capable of anything, than we think, in the direst of times, when it seems that evil is winning in dominance over the world. Through togetherness, support, love, community, connection, friendship and family, we can achieve anything.
After all, major religions, as was originally intended, are formed out of love and community, not hatred, selfishness, violence, bloodlust and division.
'Safiyyah's War' is beautifully written, and I would have read it in a day if I hadn't been so busy. It tells the story of Safiyyah, a Muslim child living in Paris at the start of WWII, and her day to day life, her curiosities, her excursions, her risks, her helping those in need however she can, her cunning, her fears, her astounding bravery, and her relationships with her loving, lovely family, and friends; such as the many Jewish and non-Jewish children (and adults, too) she meets, gets to know, and saves along the way. It is this wonderful, wandering heroic girl's coming-of-age journey, when her childhood is taken from her far too soon. I especially love how her PTSD and anxiety are depicted, becoming clearer and more prominent near the end, when the situation with the Nazis grows increasingly worse and more deathly and terrifying.
Safiyyah and those around her never lose hope, however, or they don't for long. They will not, and cannot, let evil win. They have love, and each other, and they can push forwards, through anything.
There are gorgeous, delicious descriptions of oranges (I adore Safiyyah's grandmother and her nostalgic love for the fruit). And the rest of Paris. There are books, libraries, maps (Safiyyah is a brilliant navigator, cartographer, and future explorer), paper butterflies, increasingly rationed food, and animals like little fluffy cats, and an abandoned parrot that refuses to leave his cage. 'Safiyyah's War' is like 'The Book Thief', if it was set in Paris and the main characters were Muslims, and the heroine was a bit more proactive.
This treasure of a book - this near-perfect* holy, sacred, reverent tome - is all at once adorable, lovely, scary, sad and tragic. But above all, it is ever so hopeful. It is so heartfelt and earnest, it is impossible not to feel for the characters, the setting, and its crucial intensions. We all need books like this - we always have, but especially right now. Human history is always repeating itself, and humans are determined to be doomed to make the same tragic and stupid mistakes over and over again.
In trying to write a review now do I realise how inadequate and unqualified I am to give 'Safiyyah's War' the proper, wholehearted justice and respect it deserves. So, in the remains of my incompetence, I'll leave off by saying:
It is magnificent, moral, and inspiring - and criminally underrated - children's literature. Just read it. You won't regret it. It is a reason to keep on reading books. It is a rare jewel that proves that new literature can actually be good, and well written from passion and the heart, and as vital to our survival as old books; a survival that is slowly dwindling every day in the sorry, ghastly, outrageous, pathetic, dangerous current state of affairs in the world.
'Safiyyah's War' needs to be read by everyone, to be known and recognised as the important masterpiece for all ages it is.
Never give up. Never give in to despair and hopelessness. Never surrender. Never stop caring.
Now to read more books about WWII!
I'll end by including these quotes by authors, who say more with simple, little words than I could with any long review I write:
'Safiyyah's War has the soul of a classic and the urgency of a story for our times. A tale of tolerance, unthinkable bravery, and heart-in-mouth true events. I loved this book.' - Kiran Millwood Hargrave.
'This book shines through with empathy at its very heart.' - Nizrana Farook.
'Luminously written, this is an extraordinary story of bravery filled with truth and light and hope.' - Katya Balen.
'Beautifully written, full of compassion and hope, Safiyyah's War is an important and much needed WWII story that puts a spotlight on a rarely heard of part of history. Safiyyah's story is a must-read in schools exploring WWII, to encourage empathy. The story is superbly told, with adorable characters. A special, heartfelt book that I'm glad exists.' - A M Dassu.
'Beautiful, vivid writing... A moving story of resistance and unity, the power of community and faith. I absolutely loved it.' - Radiya Hafiza.
And from the author, Hiba Noor Khan, in her Historical Note at the end of the book, a quote I feel is gravely prescient and poignant:
'I feel incredibly grateful to have the opportunity to write this story, and intend for it to be a humanising, unifying force in an all too often bitterly divided world.'
(Bitter, petty, and dangerously stupid.)
Also, at the end of her Historical Note:
'Both Jewish and Muslim tradition share the saying; For whoever saves a single life, it is as if they have saved all of humanity.'
Final Score: 4/5
*I feel a few characters get forgotten about at the end, and maybe I am hard to please, but oh well. Nothing can be perfect.
'Safiyyah's War' is a new children's book about World War II. It is based around a true life heroic story - a different, widely forgotten and erased part of history I certainly never heard of before: about how Muslims in Paris hid Jews in their mosques, as a sanctuary and refuge, and helped them escape the Nazi occupation; through the Resistance, involving secret messengers, underground tunnels, catacombs, and boats on rivers, under the cover of night.
It is a true testament to humans' limitless capacity to love, and to be compassionate, empathetic, and brave, and to preserve our spirit, no matter what tragedies befall us. We are each so much braver, and more capable of anything, than we think, in the direst of times, when it seems that evil is winning in dominance over the world. Through togetherness, support, love, community, connection, friendship and family, we can achieve anything.
After all, major religions, as was originally intended, are formed out of love and community, not hatred, selfishness, violence, bloodlust and division.
'Safiyyah's War' is beautifully written, and I would have read it in a day if I hadn't been so busy. It tells the story of Safiyyah, a Muslim child living in Paris at the start of WWII, and her day to day life, her curiosities, her excursions, her risks, her helping those in need however she can, her cunning, her fears, her astounding bravery, and her relationships with her loving, lovely family, and friends; such as the many Jewish and non-Jewish children (and adults, too) she meets, gets to know, and saves along the way. It is this wonderful, wandering heroic girl's coming-of-age journey, when her childhood is taken from her far too soon. I especially love how her PTSD and anxiety are depicted, becoming clearer and more prominent near the end, when the situation with the Nazis grows increasingly worse and more deathly and terrifying.
Safiyyah and those around her never lose hope, however, or they don't for long. They will not, and cannot, let evil win. They have love, and each other, and they can push forwards, through anything.
There are gorgeous, delicious descriptions of oranges (I adore Safiyyah's grandmother and her nostalgic love for the fruit). And the rest of Paris. There are books, libraries, maps (Safiyyah is a brilliant navigator, cartographer, and future explorer), paper butterflies, increasingly rationed food, and animals like little fluffy cats, and an abandoned parrot that refuses to leave his cage. 'Safiyyah's War' is like 'The Book Thief', if it was set in Paris and the main characters were Muslims, and the heroine was a bit more proactive.
This treasure of a book - this near-perfect* holy, sacred, reverent tome - is all at once adorable, lovely, scary, sad and tragic. But above all, it is ever so hopeful. It is so heartfelt and earnest, it is impossible not to feel for the characters, the setting, and its crucial intensions. We all need books like this - we always have, but especially right now. Human history is always repeating itself, and humans are determined to be doomed to make the same tragic and stupid mistakes over and over again.
In trying to write a review now do I realise how inadequate and unqualified I am to give 'Safiyyah's War' the proper, wholehearted justice and respect it deserves. So, in the remains of my incompetence, I'll leave off by saying:
It is magnificent, moral, and inspiring - and criminally underrated - children's literature. Just read it. You won't regret it. It is a reason to keep on reading books. It is a rare jewel that proves that new literature can actually be good, and well written from passion and the heart, and as vital to our survival as old books; a survival that is slowly dwindling every day in the sorry, ghastly, outrageous, pathetic, dangerous current state of affairs in the world.
'Safiyyah's War' needs to be read by everyone, to be known and recognised as the important masterpiece for all ages it is.
Never give up. Never give in to despair and hopelessness. Never surrender. Never stop caring.
Now to read more books about WWII!
I'll end by including these quotes by authors, who say more with simple, little words than I could with any long review I write:
'Safiyyah's War has the soul of a classic and the urgency of a story for our times. A tale of tolerance, unthinkable bravery, and heart-in-mouth true events. I loved this book.' - Kiran Millwood Hargrave.
'This book shines through with empathy at its very heart.' - Nizrana Farook.
'Luminously written, this is an extraordinary story of bravery filled with truth and light and hope.' - Katya Balen.
'Beautifully written, full of compassion and hope, Safiyyah's War is an important and much needed WWII story that puts a spotlight on a rarely heard of part of history. Safiyyah's story is a must-read in schools exploring WWII, to encourage empathy. The story is superbly told, with adorable characters. A special, heartfelt book that I'm glad exists.' - A M Dassu.
'Beautiful, vivid writing... A moving story of resistance and unity, the power of community and faith. I absolutely loved it.' - Radiya Hafiza.
And from the author, Hiba Noor Khan, in her Historical Note at the end of the book, a quote I feel is gravely prescient and poignant:
'I feel incredibly grateful to have the opportunity to write this story, and intend for it to be a humanising, unifying force in an all too often bitterly divided world.'
(Bitter, petty, and dangerously stupid.)
Also, at the end of her Historical Note:
'Both Jewish and Muslim tradition share the saying; For whoever saves a single life, it is as if they have saved all of humanity.'
Final Score: 4/5
*I feel a few characters get forgotten about at the end, and maybe I am hard to please, but oh well. Nothing can be perfect.
June 18, 2023
Wow...what a journey of discovery and learning this story took me on!
From the very first page, Hiba's writing drew me into the world of the Grand Mosque in WW2 Paris, and through her storytelling, I eagerly learnt about how the Muslims of Paris saved countless Jewish people, as part of the French Resistance effort. I will not give any more plot detail, as like me, I want the reader to be swept up in this rich, evocative and gripping narrative.
The title itself fits perfectly. Saffiyah is a courageous young girl, who feels deeply and whose actions very much reflect her sense of personal responsibility. She must be part of her community's efforts to save Jewish lives and resist the antisemitic violence and hatred perpetrated by the Nazi regime. I adored Safiyyah's sense of curiosity and how she then took the next step to action. I hope that young people take from this story, the importance of questioning and curiosity about the world around us, and where needed, see the importance of taking action and creating change.
Safiyyah’s War is such an important story based on real events that, to date, been largely missing from our wider collective consciousness surrounding WW2. Hiba's thorough research ensures accurate and respectful representation, and her end ‘Historical Note’ shares with the reader information about actual members of the Mosque community, on whom some of her characters are based. As she writes, this book uncovers “all the unlikely heroes, whose names aren’t memorialised and whose stories aren’t sung and praised, but whose courage and actions change our world forever”. Young people of Muslim faith will read this, and maybe for the first time, see that the contribution of their community, in this pivotal moment in the history of the World, is being acknowledged. I hope in reading and talking about this book, young people will be curious like Safiyyah, ask questions, research stories, and shine a light on other unsung heroes, within this and other periods in history.
This MG book needs to be in EVERY Library. Outstanding writing for children is outstanding writing for everyone, and people of all ages will take not only historical learnings, but also a challenge to the predominant stereotypes of Muslim faith and community. We need to ‘blether’ about this book! There are moments of such poignancy, that I wept and in our divided times, the message of hope that can only come through shared dialogue, empathy and understanding, is one we all desperately need to hear.
From the very first page, Hiba's writing drew me into the world of the Grand Mosque in WW2 Paris, and through her storytelling, I eagerly learnt about how the Muslims of Paris saved countless Jewish people, as part of the French Resistance effort. I will not give any more plot detail, as like me, I want the reader to be swept up in this rich, evocative and gripping narrative.
The title itself fits perfectly. Saffiyah is a courageous young girl, who feels deeply and whose actions very much reflect her sense of personal responsibility. She must be part of her community's efforts to save Jewish lives and resist the antisemitic violence and hatred perpetrated by the Nazi regime. I adored Safiyyah's sense of curiosity and how she then took the next step to action. I hope that young people take from this story, the importance of questioning and curiosity about the world around us, and where needed, see the importance of taking action and creating change.
Safiyyah’s War is such an important story based on real events that, to date, been largely missing from our wider collective consciousness surrounding WW2. Hiba's thorough research ensures accurate and respectful representation, and her end ‘Historical Note’ shares with the reader information about actual members of the Mosque community, on whom some of her characters are based. As she writes, this book uncovers “all the unlikely heroes, whose names aren’t memorialised and whose stories aren’t sung and praised, but whose courage and actions change our world forever”. Young people of Muslim faith will read this, and maybe for the first time, see that the contribution of their community, in this pivotal moment in the history of the World, is being acknowledged. I hope in reading and talking about this book, young people will be curious like Safiyyah, ask questions, research stories, and shine a light on other unsung heroes, within this and other periods in history.
This MG book needs to be in EVERY Library. Outstanding writing for children is outstanding writing for everyone, and people of all ages will take not only historical learnings, but also a challenge to the predominant stereotypes of Muslim faith and community. We need to ‘blether’ about this book! There are moments of such poignancy, that I wept and in our divided times, the message of hope that can only come through shared dialogue, empathy and understanding, is one we all desperately need to hear.
July 31, 2024
A must-read for middle-grade children everywhere!
Based on true events in Paris, this historical fiction for MG readers tells the story of how, during WWII, the Muslim community at the Grand Mosque secretly helped their Jewish neighbors from the Nazis, saving up to 1,700 lives.
”It is only in holy places of worship and libraries that you have to whisper, for they are both sacred in their own special ways.”
I appreciate how the author avoided politics and propaganda, and focused instead on courage, familial love, and friendships. Highlighting the often-forgotten heroism of Muslims in France, this book offers an important and inspiring narrative for young readers.
Saffiyah is a kind-hearted and brave young girl. But she’s also rebellious and quite bold! Some of the things she does often felt unbelievable for someone her age, but I suppose their purpose is to keep young readers interested in the book through her adventures.
My favorite character is Saffiya’s grandmother, Setti. She’s wise, strong, and kind.
The story is fast-paced and maintains a constant sense of danger, yet it still deeply explores relationships, character growth, and religious understanding. The themes of community and unity in adverse times are portrayed powerfully and memorably.
Based on true events in Paris, this historical fiction for MG readers tells the story of how, during WWII, the Muslim community at the Grand Mosque secretly helped their Jewish neighbors from the Nazis, saving up to 1,700 lives.
”It is only in holy places of worship and libraries that you have to whisper, for they are both sacred in their own special ways.”
I appreciate how the author avoided politics and propaganda, and focused instead on courage, familial love, and friendships. Highlighting the often-forgotten heroism of Muslims in France, this book offers an important and inspiring narrative for young readers.
Saffiyah is a kind-hearted and brave young girl. But she’s also rebellious and quite bold! Some of the things she does often felt unbelievable for someone her age, but I suppose their purpose is to keep young readers interested in the book through her adventures.
My favorite character is Saffiya’s grandmother, Setti. She’s wise, strong, and kind.
The story is fast-paced and maintains a constant sense of danger, yet it still deeply explores relationships, character growth, and religious understanding. The themes of community and unity in adverse times are portrayed powerfully and memorably.
June 23, 2024
"Or maybe, Maria, if we all shared what we have, then everyone would be all right."
"Yes, just because someone is from another country or town doesn't mean they have less right to food and a home. " Or because someone is from another religion."
Such a powerful middle grade book! This historical retelling of how the Grand Mosque in France played a role in helping Jews in WW2 was told from a Muslim's perspective.
Our main character, Safiyyah, is a brave young girl who seeks to protect all regardless of their age, race, and religion from the German soldiers.
I appreciated the perspective of a child and Muslim for a different view on this time in history. The group of characters in this story are all so likeable including the non-human kind. You want them all to escape and spread their wings.
And let's not forget about that gorgeous cover 😍
Thank you for the e-ARC @harpercollinschin !
"Yes, just because someone is from another country or town doesn't mean they have less right to food and a home. " Or because someone is from another religion."
Such a powerful middle grade book! This historical retelling of how the Grand Mosque in France played a role in helping Jews in WW2 was told from a Muslim's perspective.
Our main character, Safiyyah, is a brave young girl who seeks to protect all regardless of their age, race, and religion from the German soldiers.
I appreciated the perspective of a child and Muslim for a different view on this time in history. The group of characters in this story are all so likeable including the non-human kind. You want them all to escape and spread their wings.
And let's not forget about that gorgeous cover 😍
Thank you for the e-ARC @harpercollinschin !
May 7, 2024
*Thanks to NetGalley for an eARC of this book*
I'm going to guess that most people have never heard of the history that this story is based on. I hadn't! And I've read a lot of World War II stories. This lovely middle grade book tells the story of the Grand Mosque and its inhabitants during the German occupation of Paris during World War II and they work they did to help save Jewish lives from the Holocaust.
Safiyyah is everything you want from a middle grader heroine, she is tenacious and smart and loves so fiercely. Because so little is known about this piece of history, the characters are all amalgamations of figures that were definitely there and Safiyyah is the perfect set of eyes for the reader to inhabit to learn this story.
The tension is subtle, with the looming Germans more of an off page threat than a direct set of characters, so I would say this is a fairly safe read for most middle grade readers. I had never considered that there would have been Muslims in Paris during this conflict (though that seems obvious in hindsight), but they are given a beautiful portrayal in this story against the darkness of the German threat.
I'm so glad I read this, and I hope that this work prompt more stories about the power of people over the threats we face.
I'm going to guess that most people have never heard of the history that this story is based on. I hadn't! And I've read a lot of World War II stories. This lovely middle grade book tells the story of the Grand Mosque and its inhabitants during the German occupation of Paris during World War II and they work they did to help save Jewish lives from the Holocaust.
Safiyyah is everything you want from a middle grader heroine, she is tenacious and smart and loves so fiercely. Because so little is known about this piece of history, the characters are all amalgamations of figures that were definitely there and Safiyyah is the perfect set of eyes for the reader to inhabit to learn this story.
The tension is subtle, with the looming Germans more of an off page threat than a direct set of characters, so I would say this is a fairly safe read for most middle grade readers. I had never considered that there would have been Muslims in Paris during this conflict (though that seems obvious in hindsight), but they are given a beautiful portrayal in this story against the darkness of the German threat.
I'm so glad I read this, and I hope that this work prompt more stories about the power of people over the threats we face.
April 24, 2024
Reading through the Carnegie shortlist.
I didn't think this would be my kind of book but I was very wrong. I love finding bits of history I have never heard of before. This book is set in Paris and kicks off just before the German occupation during WWII. The Great Mosque in Paris became a part of the resistance and the Muslim community stepped in to help Jewish people hide and escape.
Safiyyah is a very likeable protagonist, curious and brave. Her journey from a young person living with the threat of war to becoming a part of the resistance feels very real and natural.
My one criticism would be the cover: the cover feels like a book aimed at younger readers and looks more like two girls playing. It's a shame because I think some students may not pick this book up because of the cover.
Very enjoyable, especially if you are interested in stories of the war. I think this could become a favourite in my library!
I didn't think this would be my kind of book but I was very wrong. I love finding bits of history I have never heard of before. This book is set in Paris and kicks off just before the German occupation during WWII. The Great Mosque in Paris became a part of the resistance and the Muslim community stepped in to help Jewish people hide and escape.
Safiyyah is a very likeable protagonist, curious and brave. Her journey from a young person living with the threat of war to becoming a part of the resistance feels very real and natural.
My one criticism would be the cover: the cover feels like a book aimed at younger readers and looks more like two girls playing. It's a shame because I think some students may not pick this book up because of the cover.
Very enjoyable, especially if you are interested in stories of the war. I think this could become a favourite in my library!
May 19, 2024
OH. MY. GOD. This was INCREDIBLE! I didn't have huge hopes for it before I started reading because it's not something I'd typically enjoy but this has got to be one of my favourite books I've read in a while!
It was the perfect mix of everything, and had me engrossed from the first sentence. The blurb was a bit misleading as the things mentioned aren't really huge focuses in the actual book but other than that it was perfectly done.
One of those "I'd sell my soul to read for the first time again" books
It was the perfect mix of everything, and had me engrossed from the first sentence. The blurb was a bit misleading as the things mentioned aren't really huge focuses in the actual book but other than that it was perfectly done.
One of those "I'd sell my soul to read for the first time again" books
April 7, 2024
I absolutely loved this book, Hiba Noor Khan has a way with words I can’t even describe. Her book had me in tears, it was so wonderfully moving and it had me thinking, as I am studying Islam in RS at the moment. Safiyyah is a very brave young girl whose character grew throughout the book. I can definitely see why this book was in my Carnegie reads this year!
June 3, 2024
Prompted by its winning the Jhalak Prize, I sank into this incredible book this weekend. Given my own family’s history of salvation from the Nazis by nuns during WW2, I was especially moved by this story. A Muslim rector and his family, including his daughter Safiyyah, risk their own lives to save Jewish people from death by offering sanctuary in the Grand Mosque of Paris and helping them escape the country. A wondrous marvel of a book based on a true history.
May 17, 2024
I didn't really enjoy this book, but I felt obliged to finish it, because the topic and perspective is so important. I'd trust the reviews of YA readers, more than my review or the reviews of adults.
July 13, 2024
For lovers of the book thief
April 13, 2024
Well written and historically very interesting
April 3, 2024
it was interesting to see a new perspective in ww2 literature however the book was a bit babyish for me and i lost patience towards the end. i always tell myself that if a book is good i should be sad when it ends and sadly for this book it didn’t happen ;-;
September 29, 2023
A.M.A.Z.I.N.G! SubhanAllah the subject matter is incredible, but the characters, writing, and Islamic inclusion really make this 327 page book a must read for all upper middle grade and lower middle school aged children everywhere. The book is historical fiction, set in Paris during WWII, the Nazis are invading and the Muslims at the Grand Mosque of Paris are covertly helping, hiding, and saving their Jewish neighbors. Based on real facts, the book does not get lost in politics, or propaganda, or the enemy, the story stays on level for an MG reader with character arcs that are not confined to the atrocities at hand. The familial love, the friendships, the bravery of so many, really lingers long after the last page is read. Knowing that Muslims in France did this and that their stories have by-and-large been lost over time, makes this book all the more important to share with our own children. This book fills such a void for children in Western countries wondering why WWII lessons in school never mention Muslims, and that this is traditionally published in the UK, soon to be in the USA, really is a benefit to us all. I do wish the book was more strongly sourced, there are Historical Notes at the end, but I'd love to know where to go to get more facts about it all. Little kid me would have been obsessed, adult me can't wait to share this book with teachers and book clubs to discuss, teach, enjoy, and be inspired by, alhumdulillah.
SYNOPSIS:
Safiyyah lives in the apartments in the compound of the Grand Mosque and while Muslims are more-or-less safe from the imminent threat of the Nazi's, because of their connections to North Africa, their world is still changing quickly. Safiyyah loves maps, helping run errands for her father, Ammo Kader, and Ammo Imam, and spending time with her Setti. She also loves spending time with her best friend, Isabelle at school and on weekends. When the Nazi presence is no longer avoidable, Isabelle and her family leave, errands are no longer safe and Setti's beloved oranges are harder and harder to get. To top it all off, her father starts acting secretive and Safiyyah starts sneaking around to find out what is going on, unraveling a clandestine network helping those needing to get away. Her family has no intention of involving her, but when soldiers start getting suspicious of the Muslims assisting the Jews, Safiyyah takes on dangerous roles that just maybe a young girl can accomplish without drawing too much attention to herself, the cause, and the Muslim community's commitment to helping the innocent.
WHY I LIKE IT:
I love that the book is fast paced and the fear of being caught is always present, yet the book is able to flesh out relationships, character growth, and religious understanding. Little details weave in and out, and the confidence that the writer is in control of all the threads allows the reader to be swept away, completely. The interfaith aspects are not just check marks, the story shows the ease in which the communities work together and their connections are tangible. There is no internalized Islamophobia or othering, and the way that Islam emboldens the characters' actions is so beautiful: from the larger commitment for justice, to the personal internal reflections of wearing of hijab, praying, listening to the athan, making duas for the deceased, etc.. Spending time to ruminate on the idea that breaking an unjust law to save lives through an Islamic lens is empowering, and knowing that this is the risk that real Muslims in Paris took is so very humbling. I love that the conflict of France and Algeria is not left out as the Kabyle protagonist and her grandmother note that they are now supporting those wearing French uniforms to fight the Germans.
FLAGS:
Wish making, lying, death, fear, occupation, war, destruction, oath taking on a Quran, tasbeehs, working with wine barrels and smugglers. There is a strong familiarity with Christian and Jewish holidays, some crossover celebration. Some Christian angel imagery being used by Safiyyah for Ammo. Sneaking, hiding, forgery, skipping school.
TOOLS FOR LEADING THE DISCUSSION:
Having only ever read one other book on this topic, The Grand Mosque of Paris, that would definitely be a reference I would present when introducing the book. Whether in a classroom, a library, a home, a book club, I hope this book gets read, passed around, shared, and discussed. Muslims and non Muslims alike will fall in love with persistent over-eager Safiyyah and hopefully remember the resistance the characters in the book and real life sought with courage and dedication for the good of humanity.
SYNOPSIS:
Safiyyah lives in the apartments in the compound of the Grand Mosque and while Muslims are more-or-less safe from the imminent threat of the Nazi's, because of their connections to North Africa, their world is still changing quickly. Safiyyah loves maps, helping run errands for her father, Ammo Kader, and Ammo Imam, and spending time with her Setti. She also loves spending time with her best friend, Isabelle at school and on weekends. When the Nazi presence is no longer avoidable, Isabelle and her family leave, errands are no longer safe and Setti's beloved oranges are harder and harder to get. To top it all off, her father starts acting secretive and Safiyyah starts sneaking around to find out what is going on, unraveling a clandestine network helping those needing to get away. Her family has no intention of involving her, but when soldiers start getting suspicious of the Muslims assisting the Jews, Safiyyah takes on dangerous roles that just maybe a young girl can accomplish without drawing too much attention to herself, the cause, and the Muslim community's commitment to helping the innocent.
WHY I LIKE IT:
I love that the book is fast paced and the fear of being caught is always present, yet the book is able to flesh out relationships, character growth, and religious understanding. Little details weave in and out, and the confidence that the writer is in control of all the threads allows the reader to be swept away, completely. The interfaith aspects are not just check marks, the story shows the ease in which the communities work together and their connections are tangible. There is no internalized Islamophobia or othering, and the way that Islam emboldens the characters' actions is so beautiful: from the larger commitment for justice, to the personal internal reflections of wearing of hijab, praying, listening to the athan, making duas for the deceased, etc.. Spending time to ruminate on the idea that breaking an unjust law to save lives through an Islamic lens is empowering, and knowing that this is the risk that real Muslims in Paris took is so very humbling. I love that the conflict of France and Algeria is not left out as the Kabyle protagonist and her grandmother note that they are now supporting those wearing French uniforms to fight the Germans.
FLAGS:
Wish making, lying, death, fear, occupation, war, destruction, oath taking on a Quran, tasbeehs, working with wine barrels and smugglers. There is a strong familiarity with Christian and Jewish holidays, some crossover celebration. Some Christian angel imagery being used by Safiyyah for Ammo. Sneaking, hiding, forgery, skipping school.
TOOLS FOR LEADING THE DISCUSSION:
Having only ever read one other book on this topic, The Grand Mosque of Paris, that would definitely be a reference I would present when introducing the book. Whether in a classroom, a library, a home, a book club, I hope this book gets read, passed around, shared, and discussed. Muslims and non Muslims alike will fall in love with persistent over-eager Safiyyah and hopefully remember the resistance the characters in the book and real life sought with courage and dedication for the good of humanity.
August 5, 2024
Safiyyah’s WAR by Hiba Noor Khan an exceptional realistic historical fiction tale for 10 to 14-year-olds and beyond. I consider this to be a must read for teachers (especially social studies, history, and literature teaches), obviously students, parents of those students, leaders and practitioners of Jewish and Muslim traditions, and anyone interested in a story based on the fact that early in World War II Muslims in Frace saved many Jewish lives.
Safiyyah is an 11-year-old Muslim living in the Grand Mosque in Paris and the Nazis are in Paris and are likely to make a sweep through the city and take all the Jews away. She has no idea her father is secretly organizing and shepherding Jews to safety and when she does find out her father asks her to play a couple of different and dangerously important roles in the effort to save many Jews.
Here is what critics have said.
Kirkus writes in their starred review: “The book’s messages of interfaith cooperation and respect for human dignity are timely and compelling. A must-read distinguished by its powerful plot and poignant writing.”
Just Imagine located in the United Kingdom is source for news, opinions, interviews with educators and authors and practical advice for practicing teachers and school librarians. And Just Imagine write: “Safiyyah’s War is a superb middle-grade historical novel which tells the incredible, inspiring and little-known story of the role of the Grand Mosque in Paris in saving Jews during the Second World War as part of tshe French Resistance.”
WritersMosaic, a division of the Royal Literary Fund, is an online magazine and developmental resource focused on UK writers. And here is what they write about Khan’s work: “Safiyyah’s War is a refreshing and heartfelt World War II story. It follows Safiyyah as the threat of German invasion turns her comfortable Parisian world upside down. The story, told in close third person, challenges our ideas of this historical period by throwing light on a true to life humanitarian mission; the saving of many Jewish lives by the rector of the Grand Paris Mosque, Ben Ghabrit. It does a wonderful job of confronting stereotypes as it tells of individuals of Islamic faith who put their own safety at risk to help their Jewish neighbors. It paints a positive picture of the close-knit communities of Paris in the 1940s working together to keep everyone safe. Khan’s prose flows as smoothly as the Seine in this empathetic, hopeful story. In the light of recent religious conflict, the message of helping one’s neighbor is even more poignant.”
This historical fiction piece is based on facts related to the early stages of war and the heroic actions of French Muslim citizens.
This is an excellent read. I highly recommend it.
Safiyyah is an 11-year-old Muslim living in the Grand Mosque in Paris and the Nazis are in Paris and are likely to make a sweep through the city and take all the Jews away. She has no idea her father is secretly organizing and shepherding Jews to safety and when she does find out her father asks her to play a couple of different and dangerously important roles in the effort to save many Jews.
Here is what critics have said.
Kirkus writes in their starred review: “The book’s messages of interfaith cooperation and respect for human dignity are timely and compelling. A must-read distinguished by its powerful plot and poignant writing.”
Just Imagine located in the United Kingdom is source for news, opinions, interviews with educators and authors and practical advice for practicing teachers and school librarians. And Just Imagine write: “Safiyyah’s War is a superb middle-grade historical novel which tells the incredible, inspiring and little-known story of the role of the Grand Mosque in Paris in saving Jews during the Second World War as part of tshe French Resistance.”
WritersMosaic, a division of the Royal Literary Fund, is an online magazine and developmental resource focused on UK writers. And here is what they write about Khan’s work: “Safiyyah’s War is a refreshing and heartfelt World War II story. It follows Safiyyah as the threat of German invasion turns her comfortable Parisian world upside down. The story, told in close third person, challenges our ideas of this historical period by throwing light on a true to life humanitarian mission; the saving of many Jewish lives by the rector of the Grand Paris Mosque, Ben Ghabrit. It does a wonderful job of confronting stereotypes as it tells of individuals of Islamic faith who put their own safety at risk to help their Jewish neighbors. It paints a positive picture of the close-knit communities of Paris in the 1940s working together to keep everyone safe. Khan’s prose flows as smoothly as the Seine in this empathetic, hopeful story. In the light of recent religious conflict, the message of helping one’s neighbor is even more poignant.”
This historical fiction piece is based on facts related to the early stages of war and the heroic actions of French Muslim citizens.
This is an excellent read. I highly recommend it.
June 19, 2023
I really liked the sound of this book. I enjoy historical novels and this was something I really knew nothing about. I ended up dreaming about what might happen next! The praise for this book by other authors is not to be sniffed at!
Safiyyah is the daughter of her Baba and Yemma, she has a younger sister, Fatima, and her grandmother, Setti, lives with them as well. They live in the mosque in Paris as members of the staff there. As we start the book Safiyyah is in her favourite place - the library - and as usual she is looking at maps and eating Madame Odette's bonbons! Madame is the librarian, she finds Safiyyah's fascination with maps quite special. She has to rush home because Yemma told her she needs to be on time. But on the way she sees a man holding a child's hand and crying - in the street. When she tells Baba he says the man could be Jewish, and the war is not good for them, but she doesn't know why. It is wartime - the French are just about holding off the Germans, but not for long.
This changes their lives forever. Safiyyah's best friend Isabelle's family are one of the first to leave Paris, first going to their house in the country then to England. Many of the wealthy residents do the same.
Baba and Ammo Kader are keeping secrets from her - she's always been allowed to help in the office - but now it's locked. And why is Baba going out late at night?
Safiyyah is shocked when she finds out - and even more shocked when her friend Timothée brings her news that her father has been arrested - thankfully he is released. However the alternative is for Safiyyah to run errands. This at least gave her the chance to visit Monsieur Cassin, her botanist friend whose apartment was full of the plants he loved and was writing about.
What are Baba and Ammo Kader doing? How are they helping? And can they continue now, and in fact go further with their help?
I knew nothing of this story. We all know of the resistance but for one community to help another in such a way, putting themselves at risk too was clearly a step beyond. In the historical note it tells us that both Muslim and Jewish faiths share a saying "For whoever saves a single life, it is as if they have saved all of humanity".
I loved this book. It was difficult too stop reading despite being sad at times. Safiyyah, although fictional, is a strong character that can easily be imagined in this role, and her sense of duty to her family and friends is unwavering.
Safiyyah is the daughter of her Baba and Yemma, she has a younger sister, Fatima, and her grandmother, Setti, lives with them as well. They live in the mosque in Paris as members of the staff there. As we start the book Safiyyah is in her favourite place - the library - and as usual she is looking at maps and eating Madame Odette's bonbons! Madame is the librarian, she finds Safiyyah's fascination with maps quite special. She has to rush home because Yemma told her she needs to be on time. But on the way she sees a man holding a child's hand and crying - in the street. When she tells Baba he says the man could be Jewish, and the war is not good for them, but she doesn't know why. It is wartime - the French are just about holding off the Germans, but not for long.
This changes their lives forever. Safiyyah's best friend Isabelle's family are one of the first to leave Paris, first going to their house in the country then to England. Many of the wealthy residents do the same.
Baba and Ammo Kader are keeping secrets from her - she's always been allowed to help in the office - but now it's locked. And why is Baba going out late at night?
Safiyyah is shocked when she finds out - and even more shocked when her friend Timothée brings her news that her father has been arrested - thankfully he is released. However the alternative is for Safiyyah to run errands. This at least gave her the chance to visit Monsieur Cassin, her botanist friend whose apartment was full of the plants he loved and was writing about.
What are Baba and Ammo Kader doing? How are they helping? And can they continue now, and in fact go further with their help?
I knew nothing of this story. We all know of the resistance but for one community to help another in such a way, putting themselves at risk too was clearly a step beyond. In the historical note it tells us that both Muslim and Jewish faiths share a saying "For whoever saves a single life, it is as if they have saved all of humanity".
I loved this book. It was difficult too stop reading despite being sad at times. Safiyyah, although fictional, is a strong character that can easily be imagined in this role, and her sense of duty to her family and friends is unwavering.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 170 reviews