Melissa (Trying to Catch Up)'s Reviews > The Trap

The Trap by Catherine Ryan Howard
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
721595
's review

liked it

2.5 stars
I was pretty disappointed in this book because I've liked Howard's last few books quite a bit. This one suffered from some issues.

It is the story of Lucy, whose sister Nicki disappeared a year ago and has started taking it into her own hands to try to flush out her kidnapper. She puts herself in dangerous situations in order to possibly be taken by the same man, she just wants to know what happened to her sister. The police have a task force and are working to find Nicki, as well as some other missing women that appear to have been taken in a similar manner. Two women, peripheral members of the police, think there may be even more victims.

I wanted to like this one so much, and many of my reviewer friends have loved it. I just didn't connect with any part of the story, it took me much longer to get through this book than I normally would have. It's really disjointed, skipping from perspective to perspective and timeline to timeline. There are times where you don't have any idea whose head you're in--that is the point when you get to some of the twists because sometimes you will believe you're in one character's head when it really was another one entirely, and the same thing with timelines.

This created a chaotic type of reading experience for me, I wanted it to be more cohesive and way less scattered. There are parts that are police procedural, yet just when I got into that groove it would switch to the villain's POV, then abruptly we go to Lucy's POV just long enough to gain momentum, then another switch. Even though that should have made the book fast paced, it slowed it way down for me. The premise is good overall and I like missing people stories!

Then I must talk about the ending. Ugh. Didn't like it.

Many, many people have loved this one, but I'm not one of them. Waving from outlier island.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
103 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Trap.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 21, 2023 – Shelved
March 21, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
July 29, 2023 – Started Reading
August 2, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 55 (55 new)


Sherri Thacker I liked this one and gave it 4 stars.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Sherri wrote: "I liked this one and gave it 4 stars."

I am hoping to have more reading time this week. I always think--oh, it's summer, I will have a ton of reading time, but nope.


Tara (Not Receiving Notifications 🔔 ) Sorry, this didn’t work for you, Melissa!! I understand were you’re coming from! Thank you for a Fair honest review.


Rachel Hanes Uh-oh! I keep seeing mixed reviews for this one now… I still plan on reading it, but I won’t keep my expectations super high. Sorry you didn’t enjoy this one more. Great review, Melissa!


theliterateleprechaun I need to take notes from your reviews on how to write a review of a book I didn't enjoy. Thanks for sharing this review and for your honesty.


Shelley's Book Nook Bummer. I have read other bad reviews for this one. Thanks for your honesty, Melissa. 💕🤗


Holly  B (slower pace!) Waving back from Outlier Island 🏝💕


message 8: by Deeksha (new)

Deeksha Bhardwaj So sorry this was so chaotic. Hope your next read is better! Excellent review, Melissa💗


megs_bookrack Great review, Melissa! I am reading this right now and while I'm enjoying it, I completely agree with it feeling disjointed. I just had to skip back like 10-chapters to read it all again because I got almost done and was like wait a minute...something I thought I had understood from earlier on was incorrect. I think I got confused when it was skipping between perspectives, I thought something I had read was one perspective but it was really another...LOL. So yeah, needless to say, I definitely get what you're saying!


Jayme Sorry this was a MISS for you! Hope you love your next! 💞


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Tara —on semi-hiatus wrote: "Sorry, this didn’t work for you, Melissa!! I understand were you’re coming from! Thank you for a Fair honest review."

Thanks Tara!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Rachel wrote: "Uh-oh! I keep seeing mixed reviews for this one now… I still plan on reading it, but I won’t keep my expectations super high. Sorry you didn’t enjoy this one more. Great review, Melissa!"

I hope you like it more than I did!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) theliterateleprechaun wrote: "I need to take notes from your reviews on how to write a review of a book I didn't enjoy. Thanks for sharing this review and for your honesty."

LOL I felt like I was writing in circles but that is how I felt while reading!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "Bummer. I have read other bad reviews for this one. Thanks for your honesty, Melissa. 💕🤗"

Thanks Shelley!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Holly wrote: "Waving back from Outlier Island 🏝💕"

We definitely felt similarly about this one.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Deeksha wrote: "So sorry this was so chaotic. Hope your next read is better! Excellent review, Melissa💗"

Thanks Deeksha!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) megs_bookrack wrote: "Great review, Melissa! I am reading this right now and while I'm enjoying it, I completely agree with it feeling disjointed. I just had to skip back like 10-chapters to read it all again because I ..."
It works sometimes when it is done sparingly, once in a book or maybe twice at the most, but this one just over used that plot device.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Jayme wrote: "Sorry this was a MISS for you! Hope you love your next! 💞"

Thanks Jayme!


message 19: by Heidi (new)

Heidi Bummer that this wasn’t as good as her other books— as always, appreciate the honest review!!


MarilynW I'm listening to this one right now, not sure what to think yet. Wonderful review, Melissa!


message 21: by Holly (new)

Holly Hmm I was on the fence about this one so I appreciate your review!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Heidi wrote: "Bummer that this wasn’t as good as her other books— as always, appreciate the honest review!!"

Thanks Heidi!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) MarilynW wrote: "I'm listening to this one right now, not sure what to think yet. Wonderful review, Melissa!"

I was wondering if it was because I usually listen to her books rather than reading them. I'll look forward to your thoughts. Maybe this one is better on audio.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Carol wrote: "Oh no! I am so sorry this one didn’t work for you! Hope your next read is much better, Melissa 💙!!!"

Thanks Carol!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Holly wrote: "Hmm I was on the fence about this one so I appreciate your review!"

Thanks Holly!


message 26: by Nikki (new) - added it

Nikki Lee Fabulous review Melissa, hope your next book is great


Bec (becbingesbooks) - sorry, behind with lots of catching up to do Damn! Sorry to hear this one disappointed after the last few. A few endings are lacking lately. Great review, Melissa 🖤


Heather Adores Books Well poo, I've got this one on my list. Fair review, Melissa!


message 29: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Sorry the book didn't work. Superb review, Melissa.


Margaret M - (too far behind to catch up although trying to spend more time on GR) Fabulous review Melissa 💖


message 31: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Sounds like a one star for me....hard pass...thanx for the critique !


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Nikki wrote: "Fabulous review Melissa, hope your next book is great"

Thanks Nikki!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Bec (becbingesbooks) wrote: "Damn! Sorry to hear this one disappointed after the last few. A few endings are lacking lately. Great review, Melissa 🖤"

Thanks, it was definitely disappointing.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Heather Adores Books wrote: "Well poo, I've got this one on my list. Fair review, Melissa!"

So many people have loved it so maybe you will!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Srivalli wrote: "Sorry the book didn't work. Superb review, Melissa."

Thanks Srivalli!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Margaret M - wrote: "Fabulous review Melissa 💖"

Thanks Margaret!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Jaidee wrote: "Sounds like a one star for me....hard pass...thanx for the critique !"

Thanks Jaidee!


Kaceey Terrific review Melissa! Sorry this one didn’t work for you!💞


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Kaceey wrote: "Terrific review Melissa! Sorry this one didn’t work for you!💞"

Thanks Kaceey!


Diane Dachota I also thought it was disjointed but gave it a higher rating just because I like the author so much


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Diane wrote: "I also thought it was disjointed but gave it a higher rating just because I like the author so much"

I like her too, definitely will read another one of hers.


message 42: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Sorry this was a dud, Melissa. Great review though!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Rosh (Trying to catch up!) wrote: "Sorry this was a dud, Melissa. Great review though!"

Thanks Rosh!


Lit with Leigh NOOOOO *drops to knees* 😂😂😂 tbh this seems like a book you're either rocking with or you're not. I've seen several reviews expressing sentiments similar to yours. I'm sorry it didn't work for you!! Great review as usual 💗💗💗


MarilynW I ended up "enjoying" it but am freaked out by the story at the same time. I cannot relate to some of the women in this story but I wouldn't mind following the detective and Angela around in the future. Once again, great review, Melissa!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) GirlWithThePinkSkiMask wrote: "NOOOOO *drops to knees* 😂😂😂 tbh this seems like a book you're either rocking with or you're not. I've seen several reviews expressing sentiments similar to yours. I'm sorry it didn't work for you!!..."

It does seem to be one way or the other for this one!


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) MarilynW wrote: "I ended up "enjoying" it but am freaked out by the story at the same time. I cannot relate to some of the women in this story but I wouldn't mind following the detective and Angela around in the fu..."

Thanks Marilyn, I wouldn't mind that either!


message 48: by Donne (new)

Donne Great review, Melissa. I hemmed and hawed about this one for a while before finally adding it to my to-read list. CRH hasn't been a big hit with me; I've never given the stuff I've read of her work more than 3stars. However, a lot of people I follow really liked it so I followed the crowd and added it. Time will tell if it's another CRH 3star read for me.


Melissa (Trying to Catch Up) Donne wrote: "Great review, Melissa. I hemmed and hawed about this one for a while before finally adding it to my to-read list. CRH hasn't been a big hit with me; I've never given the stuff I've read of her work..."

For me, I almost always give her books 4 stars, because I like the unique storylines. This one just didn't resonate with me as much as the others. I'll be interested to see what you think.


Rachel Hanes Melissa, I just re-read your review and you said it perfectly- this book is disjointed!! It was all over the place. And like you, I felt like it took me forever to read this, and the ending- I don’t even want to talk about it…


« previous 1
back to top