Esil's Reviews > Beyond Belief: My Secret Life Inside Scientology and My Harrowing Escape
Beyond Belief: My Secret Life Inside Scientology and My Harrowing Escape
by
by
I listened to the audio of Beyond Belief. I could have been listening to some kind of scary fiction, but I was hearing the author's story of her life growing up in the church of Scientology. I didn't know much about Scientology before starting other than it seems to attract a bunch of celebrities and it is based on the sci-fi thoughts of L. Ron Hubbard. Jenna Miscavige Hill is the niece of the leader who succeeded Hubbard. Her parents moved onto one of the church's bases when she was two years old. And she spent the next 18 years or so of her life living in a crazy world in which she was separated from her parents for years at a time, performed countless hours of child labour, was deprived of a true education and instead subjected to endless mindless sessions of what can only be described as brain washing, was severely punished for any attempts to rebel, and ultimately made her way out of the church to become an outspoken supporter of other former church members. The world she describes is indeed "beyond belief", but Jenna clearly has a strength of character that has allowed her to emerge with a strong sense of self and purpose, and to that extent at least the book is very positive. Don't read this book if you are looking for a shocking or scandalous narrative that reveals the secrets of various celebrities or church members. Rather, Hill's narrative is a slow methodical description of her life in the church and her escape. She describes what happened from her perspective as it was happening, without inserting information she now knows about what was really going on -- this comes more toward the end of the narrative. To me, this is what made it so powerful -- such an unconsciounable way to raise a child is described in a simple deadpan fashion -- slowly Jenna comes to realize that the world she understands as normal is small, insular and abusive, and that she doesn't have to be part of that world. The audio version was particularly good because the narrator's voice uses just the right tone to convey this world as seen through a child's eyes, then as a teenager and finally as a young adult.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Beyond Belief.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Diane S ☔
(new)
Dec 10, 2015 08:41AM
Wow, Esil. Don't know much about it either but I did buy the newest book out . Curious about it too. Super review.
reply
|
flag
Diane S ❄ wrote: "Wow, Esil. Don't know much about it either but I did buy the newest book out . Curious about it too. Super review."
Thanks Diane. I might read the other book you're referring to. This one certainly made me interested in the topic but I think I have my fill of Scientology for a little while.
Thanks Diane. I might read the other book you're referring to. This one certainly made me interested in the topic but I think I have my fill of Scientology for a little while.
Fascinating story, Esil! I had to google her name for more information. I was curious because her aunt, the wife of the current leader, hasn't been seen since 2007.
Carol wrote: "Fascinating story, Esil! I had to google her name for more information. I was curious because her aunt, the wife of the current leader, hasn't been seen since 2007."
Thanks Carol. That's interesting because Shelly Miscavige plays a big role in Jenna's story until 2007 when Jenna starts leaving Scientology.
Thanks Carol. That's interesting because Shelly Miscavige plays a big role in Jenna's story until 2007 when Jenna starts leaving Scientology.
Esil wrote: "Carol wrote: "Fascinating story, Esil! I had to google her name for more information. I was curious because her aunt, the wife of the current leader, hasn't been seen since 2007."
Thanks Carol. Th..."
Yes, it is interesting. I have read that certain ex-members have tried to locate her whereabouts with no success.
Thanks Carol. Th..."
Yes, it is interesting. I have read that certain ex-members have tried to locate her whereabouts with no success.
Outstanding review Esil. I too know nothing about Scientology, but your summary definitely made me curious. I might try the audio of this one too... Thanks my friend!
Angela M wrote: "Great review , Esil . I didn't know much more than you said you did either . Interesting and scary!"
Thanks Angela! Scary and sad. It sounds like many families have been torn apart by Scientology
Thanks Angela! Scary and sad. It sounds like many families have been torn apart by Scientology
Iris wrote: "Outstanding review Esil. I too know nothing about Scientology, but your summary definitely made me curious. I might try the audio of this one too... Thanks my friend!"
You're welcome Iris. The audio really worked for me. I think it made what might seem at times like a bit of a mechanical recitation of facts more engaging. I'll be interested to read your reaction
You're welcome Iris. The audio really worked for me. I think it made what might seem at times like a bit of a mechanical recitation of facts more engaging. I'll be interested to read your reaction
Jen wrote: "Great review - it is rather interesting this whole brain washing thing. Scary is right!"
Thanks Jen. It's hard to understand how it happens, but the author has some pretty good insight into how hard it was to stop believing
Thanks Jen. It's hard to understand how it happens, but the author has some pretty good insight into how hard it was to stop believing
Is it me or are there lots of anti-Scientology books out-there? Not that I have anything against that, given that I'm a devout Atheist and all. ;-) I saw an interview with Jenna on 60 minute or something similar. Horrendous!
Bianca wrote: "Is it me or are there lots of anti-Scientology books out-there? Not that I have anything against that, given that I'm a devout Atheist and all. ;-) I saw an interview with Jenna on 60 minute or som..."
There do seem to be a few of them floating around. But there is indeed a real and horrendous story to be told.
There do seem to be a few of them floating around. But there is indeed a real and horrendous story to be told.
Barbara wrote: "This is a great book illuminating what goes on in Scientology. It's crazy!!"
Thanks Barbara. I completely agree.
Thanks Barbara. I completely agree.
Fantastic job on your review, Esil. I have the Leah Remini (probably spelled that wrong) one but haven't gotten around to it yet. However, I wouldn't mind reading this one as well as the viewpoint is likely completely different.
Well done!!
Well done!!
Deanna wrote: "Fantastic job on your review, Esil. I have the Leah Remini (probably spelled that wrong) one but haven't gotten around to it yet. However, I wouldn't mind reading this one as well as the viewpoint ..."
Thanks Deanna. This one is definitely worth reading if you're interested in this topic. I might get to the Remini book at some point
Thanks Deanna. This one is definitely worth reading if you're interested in this topic. I might get to the Remini book at some point