Lau ♡'s Reviews > Bad Judgment

Bad Judgment by Sidney Bell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
116297579
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: romance, romance-mm, lgbt-gay, lgbt-plus, romance-thriller-or-suspense
Read 2 times. Last read June 4, 2023 to June 9, 2023.

Brogan is not very happy about the new client he has to protect, but all his complaints disappear when he meets the assistant of said new client. Embry Ford is a dream come true, and Brogan is not someone who lets an opportunity like that pass. It doesn’t matter if Embry is taken, refuses to answer him or has enough secrets to make a sane person run away. Brogan is willing to risk everything to help the man he’s falling for. Even his life.


Bad Judgment is a fast-paced suspense romance between a bodyguard with a hero complex and a mysterious guy hungry for revenge. Emotional, dark and a bit amoral at times, it shows how love has the power to save, but also to drive us to commit unthinkable crimes.


I don’t think it was a bad story, but I was so annoyed with Brogan I was unable to see past it. I found his behavior confusing. I couldn’t help but imagine myself as Embry, trying to work while the bodyguard of my boss keeps talking to me out of the blue. Maybe in another context I wouldn’t mind, if this was a rom-com with teens as MCs, but the way Brogan approached Embry felt immature and unprofessional.


“You’d open a vein for me if I asked you to, and I don’t deserve it.”


On top of that, I didn’t really understand why he was so obsessed with Embry. Embry was screaming 'bad decision' yet Brogan decided to somehow ignore it and let himself free fall. I know not everyone is very responsible when it comes to love, but it almost seemed like Embry being a potential criminal was a turn on for him. I could not understand how someone can fall in love and trust a complete stranger when his actions are telling you that he can be trouble-the kind of trouble that puts you both in jail. What I’m trying to say is that, if this wasn’t a romance book, Brogan would be dead before the book started. Because the self preservation gene was not passed to him.


The writing and the pace were good, so I think it was more my problem with Brogan’s judgment that the book itself-maybe I should have read the title more slowly. I can see it being a solid read if you don't spend the book being annoyed at one of the characters.


Dear Alexandra, hope you don't hate me after this. I promise I tried 😭😭 I really appreciate the rec and I'll be trying other books by the author xx
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Bad Judgment.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 4, 2023 – Started Reading
June 9, 2023 – Shelved as: romance
June 9, 2023 – Shelved as: romance-mm
June 9, 2023 – Shelved as: lgbt-gay
June 9, 2023 – Shelved as: lgbt-plus
June 9, 2023 – Shelved as: romance-thriller-or-suspense
June 9, 2023 – Finished Reading
September 20, 2024 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Kati *☆・゚ [a bit distracted atm] oh no, sorry for the bust. The premise sounds so good!!! 😢


Lau ♡ @Kati yess, it was! Most people loved this one and i see why. I just couldn't get Brogan 😭😭 thank youu 💛


message 3: by Arini (new)

Arini this sounds like a romance that dont make sense...but i guess its not love if it makes sense 🤣 sorry this didnt work. hope your next MM is better. great review, Lau! 💗


Lau ♡ Thank you so much, Arini!!💛 One of the MCs just didn't make sense for me. But you are right, romance doens't really make sense. I just wished I was able to still get along with it.


message 5: by Tears Of Venus (last edited Jun 09, 2023 04:01AM) (new)

Tears Of Venus i hate it when one character is obsessed with the other for no apparent reason...like what's so special about them? i wanna be in on the secret in order to appreciate it. 🤣

i'm sorry this was a bust, hopefully the next one will be better 💛 i would also recommend browsing Julia's shelves. she has great recs for MM romantic suspense!! :)


Lau ♡ Hi, Mina!! Hope you are doing well xx

i wanna be in on the secret in order to appreciate it Exactly! it's like okay, you will put your life in risk, but WHY lol

oh, yes, that's a good idea, i'll do that. She really does read great MM mysteries! Thank you so much 💛


message 7: by Imme (new)

Imme van Gorp Lol this sounds pretty toxic and nonsensical; I’m all for an obsessive love story, but it does need to make sense! Otherwise it just seems idiotic and fake😅 Awesome review x


Lau ♡ Thank you so much, @Imme!💛 i wouldn't call it toxic, but i didn't understand why he acted like that 🤔


message 9: by Imme (new)

Imme van Gorp @Lau — oh hahah, I interpreted the “red flags” from Embry as probably toxic behaviour, but I’m curious what his vibe was then…


message 10: by Rain (new)

Rain Such a bummer! I agree with you, it is so hard to look past a character that you don’t like or don’t agree with! Hope your next one is much much better 💜


ancientreader Aw, sorry this didn't work for you. It's one of my all-time favorites!


Lau ♡ @Imme oh no, sorry. Red flags as in 'he may end up in jail because he's playing with fire'. Let's just say Embry seemed to be doing something that may get Brogan in trouble, yet Brogan did not care. They were sweet as a couple, i just didn't get why Brogan decided to go for it despite that. Maybe I'm too responsible to get Brogan LOL


Lau ♡ Thank you so much, Rain!💜 Yes, exactly. I get that it's not really the book's fault that I didn't vibe with the MCs, but I was unable to enjoy it as I wanted bc of that 😭


Lau ♡ @ancientreader I'm glad you loved it so much! I'm sorry i didn't, I'm that person who needs to care about the characters to enjoy a romance. I don't need them to be perfect, i just need to understand them somehow. But for some reason Brogan really annoyed me 😭 thank you 💛


message 15: by EmBibliophile (new)

EmBibliophile No self preservation and the other character is a walking red flag? Yeah I can see why you didn’t enjoy this. Sorry this didn’t work for you. Hope your next read is better. xx


Lau ♡ @Em i don't get why characters are into potential criminals. there is a reason why i don't read mafia romances😭😭 I actually liked Embry, he was protecting a sweet inside, but from Brogan's position, where he could not know whether Embry was a nice person or not, only that there was something going on that can put him in trouble, i didn't understand why he decided to ignore it and fall in love 🤔 i get that it's a romance so the other love interest is cool, but Brogan wasn't supposed to know that *sighs*

thank you so much, Em!! xx


message 17: by Amina (new)

Amina Uff, it's so hard to see past a character you don't like, despite the chance that the story could be good. Especially when the romance doesn't make any sense! 😭 Still a wonderful review, Lau! 💜 Hope your next read will be a better one. 😊


message 18: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ aw sorry you didn’t like this one, lau :/ i’ve heard a lot about this author and her angsty works but her books remain on my list only bc they’re longer than what i usually read. 😂 great review!


Lau ♡ thank you so much, @Amina!💛 It was exactly that feeling. I'm really angry at myself but I really couldn't understand Brogan, he was so childish and unresponsible at the beginning 🙈


Lau ♡ @Elena Tbh i didn't even check whether they were long or not. I love long books so it would be something good for me! Also, there weren't any scenes I would have deleted (i would have deleted one of the MCs, but that is another kind of problem LOL). The pace was really good, we were always progressing. I wouldn't have minded a bit more of a slow burn at the beginning, tbh, but maybe it was because Brogan's decisions drove me a bit crazy. Thank you so much 💛


Cat the bookworm (in a semi hiatus of sorts) I’m sorry it was a miss. Sometimes I think authors are so bent upon finding new mc constellations that they forget to make them plausible 😕 I completely understand that - once you started rolling your eyes - it’s difficult to end up liking the character and the book. Fingers crossed for your next read 🤞


Lau ♡ Thank you, @Cat!💛 Yes, it was one of those books where you don't start with the right foot and then it's very difficult to fully get involved. Such a shame, the pacing and the writing was good, if only I could have understood Brogan's decisions at the beginning. The worst part is that he wasn't a bad person-he was really good, actually-, I just found frustrating his way of thinking, I couldn't really follow 🙈


Mila (Semi-Hiatus) Oh no! Guess the book really lives up to its name eh? Sorry this didn't work out for you love, hope the next one is better💛


Elena Lau ♡ wrote: "if this wasn’t a romance book, Brogan would be dead before the book started."

And what a terrible loss that would be. 😂 Great review, Lau. 😊


Lau ♡ @Mila yes, it does. He warned and i didn't listen, it's all on me 😂 thank youu!💛


Lau ♡ Thank you, @Elena💛 right? I'm tearing up just by thinking about it 😂


back to top