Joe's Reviews > Rest Is Resistance: A Manifesto

Rest Is Resistance by Tricia Hersey
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26876584
's review

liked it
bookshelves: sociology, alternate-beliefs, non-fiction, 2022

My introduction to Tricia Hersey is Rest Is Resistance: A Manifesto. Published in 2022, this came to my attention via Carmen with her excellent recent review. I'd been watching YouTube videos in which women chronicle their experiences living in their cars and without referring to Hersey or the Nap Ministry, one of the Black "car lifers" presented Hersey's thesis: rest is a form of resistance against the machine-level pace of our culture and a key to surviving poverty, exhaustion, white supremacy and capitalism with our body and mind intact.

-- When I started resting to save my life and connect with my Ancestors, I was a poor, Black, queer woman in graduate school on student loans with thousands of dollars in debt. I had been unemployed and underemployed since I was a full-time student worker in an archive library on campus barely making $12 an hour for a few hours weekly. I was also working for free as part of an internship for my studies while taking a full load of classes and caring for a six-year-old child. I am and was a first-generation adult graduate student with a child and a husband who was working fifty-plus hours a week to pay our rent while I studied. Once I finished my program, I couldn't find work in my field even after going on countless interviews. I remember sitting on my side of my bed crying because I had negative $25 in my bank account, no car and no savings. This is not a movement created by a person speaking about rest from some sort of position of privilege outside of being traumatized from capitalism and white supremacy. I'm telling you it's possible because I am the poster child and witness. Rest saved my life.

-- I watched my father get up every morning at four a.m. He would drag himself out of bed to sit at the kitchen table to read three newspapers, study his Bible and pray silently. He would do this for almost two hours before he needed to leave for work at six. I remember asking, "Why do you get up so early when you don't have to be at work until later?" He replied, "I want to have a few moments in the day that belong to just me before I clock in."

-- Resting can look like:

1. Closing your eyes for ten minutes.
2. A longer shower in silence.
3. Meditating on the couch for twenty minutes.
4. Daydreaming by staring out of a window.
5. Sipping warm tea before bed in the dark.
6. Slow dancing with yourself to slow music.
7. Experiencing a Sound Bath or other sound healing.
8. A Sun Salutation.
9. A twenty-minute timed nap.
10. Praying.
11. Crafting a small altar for your home.
12. A long, warm bath.
13. Taking regular breaks from social media.
14. Not immediately responding to texts and emails.
15. Deep listening to a full music album.
16. A meditative walk in nature.
17. Knitting, crocheting, sewing, and quilting.
18. Playing a musical instrument.
19. Deep eye contact.
20. Laughing intensely.


-- The concept of filling up your cup first, so you can have enough in it to pour to others feel off balance. It reeks of capitalist language that is now a part of our daily mantras. Language like "I will sleep when I am dead," "Rise and grind," "While they sleep, I grind," "If it doesn't make money, it doesn't make sense," "Wake up and hustle," and many more. The cup metaphor also is most often geared toward women, who, because of patriarchy and sexism, carry the burden of labor. Marginalized women, specifically Black and Latina women, make up the largest group of laborers in a capitalist system. Our labor history historically has been used to make the lives of white women less hectic and more relaxed. So when I hear and see this "filling your cup" language repeated on memes on social media and in the larger wellness community, I realize that our view of rest is still burdened with the lies of grind culture. I propose that the cups all be broken into little pieces, and we replace pouring with resting and connecting with our bodies in a way that is centered on experimentation and repair. I don't want to pour anymore.

One of Hersey's contributions is being an advocate for rest. Everywhere we turn, there are apostles for productivity: growing faster, advancing further, earning more, boosting your numbers. Slowing down, taking a breather, or daydreaming are practically heretical. The very thought of quitting seems hateful to most westerners. It makes me wonder who's benefiting from these narratives. Not people who are content with what they have. I was relieved to find reinforcement here that I'm already doing a few things on Hersey's list: taking long showers, a half hour nap after lunch on workdays and taking a walk when I get home.

Hersey includes a few personal anecdotes and I would've liked much more of that. Most of this manifesto is repetitive, with words like "grind culture," "side hustle," "white supremacy" or "capitalism" repeated over and over and over. I would've preferred a book that included interviews with social scientists, teachers, caregivers and others discussing how they burned out, how they benefited from rest and what that looked like for them. This manifesto is a good starting point, but my recommendation is to put your $13 toward rest and instead of buying this ebook, search Tricia Hersey on Google or YouTube.
95 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Rest Is Resistance.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 11, 2022 – Shelved
December 11, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
December 12, 2022 – Started Reading
December 12, 2022 –
2.0% "Rest saved my life. This is my truth. I don't need anyone else to verify this nor do I need complicated theories to support what I know to be true in my heart, my body, and my Spirit. My pilgrimage with rest as a form of resistance and liberation practice is a deeply personal one. It is one that started way before anyone heard of The Nap Ministry on social media."
December 12, 2022 –
9.0% "I am clearly stating that to center rest, naps, sleep, slowing down, and leisure in a capitalist, white supremacist, ableist, patriarchal world is to live as an outlier. A pilgrimage infused with softness, intentionality, and community care. We will not be able to interrupt the machine of grind culture alone. We need each other in more ways than we are allowed to believe."
December 12, 2022 –
24.0% "I watched my father get up every morning at four a.m. He would drag himself out of bed to sit at the kitchen table to read three newspapers, study his Bible, and pray silently. He would do this for almost two hours before he needed to leave for work at six. I remember asking, "Why do you get up so early when you don't have to be at work?" He replied, "I want to have a few moments in the day that belong to me.""
December 13, 2022 –
27.0% "The term womanist was coined by Alice Walker in 1983. It appeared in her book In Search of Our Mothers' Gardens and defines a womanist as "Wanting to know more and in greater depth than in considered 'good' foe one. Committed to survival and wholeness of entire people, male and female." For me, the beauty of womanism is its holistic view of change."
December 13, 2022 –
42.0% "Resting can look like:

1. Closing your eyes for ten minutes.
2. A longer shower in silence.
3. Meditating on the couch for twenty minutes.
4. Daydreaming by staring out of a window.
5. Sipping warm tea before bed in the dark.
6. Slow dancing with yourself to slow music.
7. Experiencing a Sound Bath or other sound healing.
8. A Sun Salutation.
9. A twenty-minute timed nap.
10. Praying.
"
December 13, 2022 –
49.0% "Like Audre Lorde, I am totally enamored and lay my body on the altar of poetry. I am a dreamer because I am a poet. In her essay "Poetry Is Not a Luxury," she poetically shares her attachment and belief in poetry as necessity for hope. I sometimes lay down and read her poetry with the hope that I will fall asleep while reading it, so I can drift off to sleep floating on her words."
December 15, 2022 –
64.0% "When I think of resistance, I envision all the small and large ways my Ancestors and family remixed and reimagined their lives in a toxic, anti-Black world. Tricksters using their own intelligence, intellect, and creativity to make a way out of no way. To make a way that was and is disinterested in the ways of this world, so the crafting of a new way became a daily ritual."
December 15, 2022 –
86.0% "I was surprised when this group of teens admitted that they didn't watch science fiction, had never seen a hard copy comic book, and had very little knowledge of the Star Wars film series. Many of them had a hard time taking themselves outside of their daily reality. This solidified my understanding of how oppression works to steal our imagination. This is particularly true for marginalized people."
December 15, 2022 – Shelved as: sociology
December 15, 2022 – Shelved as: alternate-beliefs
December 15, 2022 – Shelved as: non-fiction
December 15, 2022 – Finished Reading
December 23, 2022 – Shelved as: 2022

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Diane (new)

Diane Interesting. I can get behind the central premise. I think we all need more me-time and I hate “grind culture.” Good for you, Joe, in trying to incorporate some “rest” into your life. Too bad the book didn’t include more research. Nice review!


message 2: by Joe (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Diane wrote: "Interesting. I can get behind the central premise. I think we all need more me-time and I hate 'grind culture.' Good for you, Joe, in trying to incorporate some 'rest' into your life. Too bad the book didn’t include more research. Nice review!"

Thank you, Diane. The irony is how much more productive I am when I allow myself to slow down and rest often. Labor unions weren't radical fighting for breaks or weekends, but I think we can do more for ourselves without any laws being passed.


Carmen You read this!!!! :D :D ;D Great review! We agree on a lot of things, not least her repetitiveness. But the premise is solid, ¿no es cierto?


message 4: by Joe (last edited Dec 16, 2022 08:20PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Carmen wrote: "You read this!!!! :D :D ;D Great review! We agree on a lot of things, not least her repetitiveness. But the premise is solid, ¿no es cierto?"

All due to you, Moneypenny. Yes, her premise is rock solid. "Carpe diem" is the worst piece of advice I've ever heard. Too many of us are trying to make the most of the present but need to take a nap, go for a walk or stare out a window and make nothing of the moment like a member of the Peanuts gang. We'll get more out of life that way, I think.




Heyzel I appreciate your review wholeheartedly. I was looking for raw honesty in the reviews and yours stood out. I will start with Googling first before spending money $ on this book! Merci beaucoup Joe.


message 6: by Joe (last edited Jan 05, 2023 12:41PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Heyzel wrote: "I appreciate your review wholeheartedly. I was looking for raw honesty in the reviews and yours stood out. I will start with Googling first before spending money $ on this book! Merci beaucoup Joe."

Je vous en prie, Heyzel. I really appreciate you saying that. One on hand, I sincerely hope you don't need a book like this, but if you are burning the candle at both ends, adopting just two or three things that Hersey recommends might help.


message 7: by Robin (new)

Robin A wonderful review, Joe. I love the list of restful activities. It's so important to practice self-care and rest, and it's something that many of us sorely neglect.


message 8: by Joe (last edited Jan 07, 2023 11:17AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Robin wrote: "A wonderful review, Joe. I love the list of restful activities. It's so important to practice self-care and rest, and it's something that many of us sorely neglect."

Thank you, Robin. I love that list as well. This book is a reminder that one new thought or idea can be impactful, and for those of us pledging to read one good book a month, those can really add up.


Lisa Wheatley I would not encourage people to get out of paying the author for her work by googling her and turning to free resources on the internet rather than paying for the book. It’s not an overly pricey book and in general I would argue it is good practice to pay an author for their work rather than trying to get it for free.


Maddie I agree with Lisa, why wouldn’t you pay an author for their hard work in putting this together? And if you don’t have the money, that’s why we have libraries! To support authors but still get to take part in their work. Additionally, you just shared a whole bunch of Tricia Hersey’s work as quotes for for free…


message 11: by Joe (last edited Aug 01, 2023 03:53PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Maddie wrote: "I agree with Lisa, why wouldn’t you pay an author for their hard work in putting this together? And if you don’t have the money, that’s why we have libraries! To support authors but still get to take part in their work. Additionally, you just shared a whole bunch of Tricia Hersey’s work as quotes for for free…"

I paid for my copy. $12.99 on Kindle, though the current price looks like it's $13.99. I've supported this author with my wallet. And by posting a substantive review that includes excerpts, I'm helping support her on social media. Let me know when you've done either of those and we can continue the conversation.


message 12: by Julie (new)

Julie G Burnout is real, and I'm experiencing it myself these days. (I think a lot of us are). A message of "more rest" is not a bad one.

I think that every review on GRs promotes the book. I'm often surprised how many people add a book, even after I give it 2 stars and declare it not worth my time. Exposure is helpful, whether a reader loved the book or not.


message 13: by Joe (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Julie wrote: " Burnout is real, and I'm experiencing it myself these days. (I think a lot of us are)."

Very true, Julie. Every time someone likes or comments on this review, I reread Hersey's 20-point list on ways to rest. I would not refer to her writing otherwise, going into my Kindle to read her manifesto from start to finish, and it is a very short document.

Julie wrote: "Exposure is helpful, whether a reader loved the book or not."

I think so. I'd be fine with a one-star review raking my book over the coals for god knows what or god knows why as long as the reviewer paid for their copy and/or is promoting it for me. Thank you for sharing your opinions!


Michelle I disagree with Diane in that I don't think the book needed to include more research. I think the point was that we already have everything we need inside us. I think making this more research heavy would be the more capitalist-perfectionist way and antithetical to the book.


message 15: by Joe (last edited Aug 04, 2023 10:05AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Joe Michelle wrote: "I think making this more research heavy would be the more capitalist-perfectionist way and antithetical to the book."

But this book doesn't exist outside capitalism. It's priced at $13.99 on Kindle, which is a substantial amount of currency for those of us who are unemployed, underemployed, or watching our budgets. For that price, we expected a more substantial book. I don't have an issue with the content, but the lack of it is worth critiquing.


back to top